Comparative Analysis of Archetypal Symbols in Eucharist and Ashura: Jungian Psychology and Psychiatric Nursing Applications
Journal of Pizhūhish dar dīn va Salāmat (i.e., Research on Religion & Health),
Vol. 12 No. 4 (2026),
21 October 2026,
Background and Objectives: The decline of spiritual beliefs in modern societies has intensified mental health challenges, necessitating exploration of religious rituals’ psychological roles. This study aims to comparatively analyze archetypal symbols in the Christian Eucharist and Shiite Ashura rituals through Carl Gustav Jung’s analytical psychology, focusing on their impact on the collective unconscious and therapeutic potential in psychiatric nursing.
Methods: Employing a qualitative approach with semiotic analysis, this study examines religious texts, Jungian works, and cultural studies. Key symbols (blood, bread, suffering, purification, unity) were identified and compared using Jung’s archetypes and individuation framework, emphasizing their psychological functions across Christian and Shiite contexts.
Findings: The analysis revealed that both rituals manifest archetypes such as sacrifice, suffering hero, and rebirth, facilitating psychological integration. The Eucharist emphasizes divine redemption, while Ashura highlights social resistance. Symbols like blood and suffering foster catharsis and resilience, bridging individual and collective unconscious.
Conclusion: These rituals’ archetypal symbols offer therapeutic applications in Jungian psychotherapy and psychiatric nursing by promoting catharsis, shadow confrontation, and individuation, enhancing mental health through culturally sensitive care.