Correcting the Names of the Narrators of the Book of the Teb-ol-A’ima Based on the Books of Wasail al-Shi’a and Mostadrak al-Wasail
Journal of Pizhūhish dar dīn va Salāmat (i.e., Research on Religion & Health),
Vol. 8 No. 3 (2022),
18 September 2022
,
Page 142-155
https://doi.org/10.22037/jrrh.v8i3.32763
Abstract
Background and Objective: The book of Teb-ul-A’ima attributed to Hossein and Abdollah known as Ibna Bastam as the narrators of the fourth century, is one of the books that has collected medical hadiths. Since the name of the book indicates that its narrations have been stated by the innocent Imams (pbut), it is important to study the narrators of this book. Horre Ameli in the book Wasael al-Shia from the Shitte hadith collections and Mirza Hossein Nouri in the book Mostadrak al-Wasael which complements the book Wasael al-Shia, have quoted hadiths from the book of Teb al-A’ima in their books. The purpose of this study is to correct the names of the narrators in the common hadiths between the books of Teb al-A’ima, Wasael al-Shiah and Mostadrak al-Wasael.
Methods: In this study, which was conducted by descriptive analytical method, hadiths that were common between the books of Teb-ul-A’ima, Wasael al-Shiah and Mostadrak al-Wasael were collected and the differences in the names of the narrators of these common hadiths were examined. The authors reported no conflict of interests.
Results: In this study, it was found that the name of eight narrators were common out of the several narrators; about five narrators no description has been mentioned; two narrators have been praised and one has been both praised and reprimanded. These different descriptions related to the narrators indicate that the personal characteristics related to the narrators are not the same. Also, a narration that did not exist in the current version of Tab-ul-A’ima was identified.
Conclusion: In examining the hadiths common between the book of Teb-ul-A’ima and the books of Wasael al-Shiah and Mostadrak al-Wasael, differences were found in the names of the narrators in this study and the correct name of the narrators was determined. Also a narration that is unavailable in the current version of the book of Tabal al-A’meh on the Jame’ ul-Ahadith software 3.5 was found. As a result, this study can be considered as a correction and complement to the book of Tab-ul-Aima attributed to Ibna Bastam so that researchers can better evaluate this book.
- Common narrators; Document Correction; Mostadrak al-Wasail; Teb-ul-A’ima; Wasail al-Shia’
How to Cite
References
Ibna Bastam A. Teb al-Aemeh. Qom: Dar al-Sharif al-Rad; 1990.p.18-120. (Full Text in Arabic)
Ahmadi M, Rahmati MK. Tarikh-e Ahadith-e Shi'a. Qom: Dar al-Hadith Scientific and Cultural Institute; 2010. p. 79-80. (Full Text in Persian)
Boroujerdi S. Jame' al-Ahadith al-Shi'a. Tehran: Farhang-e Sabz Publications; 2007. V(22,23,25): p. 34,786,985. (Full Text in Arabic)
Aghabzorg-e Tehrani A. al-Zari'ah al-Tasanif al-Shi'a. Qom and Tehran: Ismailis of Qom and the Islamic Library of Tehran; 1987. V(15) p.139-40. (Full Text in Arabic)
Fattāhizādeh F, Rahmān Setāyesh MK, Vanaki F. The Method of Ayatol AllÄh Khoie in Identifying the Corruptions of Documents. Hadith Research. 2014;6(2):137-160. (Full Text in Persian)
Horr-e Ameli M. Tafsil Vasael al-Shi'a ela Tahsil-e Masael al-Shari'a. Qom: al-Bayt Institute (PBUH); 1988. p. V(2,6): 163- 432. (Full Text in Arabic)
Nouri H. Mostadrak al-Vasael va Mostanbet al-Masael. Qom: al-Bayt Institute (PBUH); 1987. V(5,16): p 103-104. (Full Text in Arabic)
Shekarbeygi N, Behtouei F, Behtouie F. Correction of a document of Ibn Tabastam's book Tabat al-A'imah based on the book of Bihar al-Anwar. Scientific Journal of Islamic Studies in the Field of Health. 2020;3(4):49-63. (Full Text in Persian)
Mofid M. al-Ekhtesas. Qom: al-Mo'tamer al-Alemi Lealfiah al-Sheikh Mofid; 1992. p 453. (Full Text in Arabic)
Ibn Babeway M. al-Moghnee. Qom: Institute imam Mahdi; 1994. p 579. (Full Text in Arabic)
Majlesi MB. Bihar al-Anwar. Beirut: Dar Ihya 'al-Torath al-Arabi; 1983. V(20). p. 59, 147, 156. (Full Text in Arabic)
Masoudi A. Ravesh-e Fahm-e Hadith. Tehran: Organization for the Study and Compilation of University Humanities Books (Samt); 2017. p 42, 61-65. (Full Text in Persian)
Farzi M. Sheikh Horre Ameli va Vasael al-Shi'a. Qom: Roshd-e Amoozesh dar Maaref Islami ; 2006;63:p 26-30. (Full Text in Persian)
Boroujerdi S. Manabe-e Feqh-e Shi'a (Tarjome Jame' Ahadith al-Shi'a). Tehran: Farhang-e Sabz Publications; 1966. V(22): p 985. (Full Text in Persian)
Safareh H. Ketabshenasi-e Ketabhay-e al-Vafi, Vasael al-Shi'a va Bihar al-Anwar. Journal of Oloom-e Qurani. 2004;33:144-64. (Full Text in Persian)
Shahrestani SJ. Vasael al-Shi'a. Journal Torathena. 1985;1:p 52-57. (Full Text in Arabic)
Hemyari A. Ghorb al-Esnad. Moassesehe al-Albayt le-Ehya al-Torath. Qom: Institute al-Albayt; 1992. p.542. (Full Text in Arabic)
Ibn Babeway M. al-Khisal. Tehran: Elmiah Islamiah; p.28. (Full Text in Arabic)
Saghafi E. al-Gharat. Translated by Abdol- Mohammad Ayati. Tehran: Vezarat-e Farhang va
Ershad-e Islami; 1995. (Full Text in Arabic)
Jadidi Nejad MR. Mo'jam Mostalahat al- Rijal va al- Deraye'a. Qom: Publishing Dar al- Hadith; 2003. p.157. (Full Text in Arabic)
Sobhani J. Osool al- Hadith va Ahkamehi fi Elm-e al- Derayat. Beirut: Dar al-Ehya al-Torath al-Arabi; p.232. (Full Text in Arabic)
Maaref M, Mozaffari R. An Investigation of Muḥaddith Nūrī’s Method in Authenticating Hadith Books at the End of Mustadrak al-Wasā’il. Quranic Sciences and Tradition. 2018;51(2):279-302. (Full Text in Persian)
Falahzadeh Abarghooei S. Ravesh-e Hadithi Mohadeth Norri dar Mostadrek al-Vasael. Hadis-e Andisheh. 2008;3(5):78-95. (Full Text in Persian)
Software the comprehensive of hadith 3.5, Computer Research Center of Islamic Sciences.
Library of the school of jurisprudence (https://lib.eshai.ir).
Hadiyan Rasanani E. Challenges of the Translations of the Quran in the Mutashabih Verses Related to the Infallibility of the Messenger of God (pbuh.) and Solutions (Case Study: Verses 12 of Surah Hood and 43 of Surah al-Tawbah). 2021; 21 (43) :275-294. (Full Text in Persian)
Shekarbeygi N, Babaeiyan T. Validation of the Document and Content of the Interpretive Narrations of the Six Days “Case Study of Vers 54, A’raf Sura”. Studies on Understanding Hadith. 2020;7(1):57-82. (Full Text in Persian)
Tousi M. Fehrest-e Kotob-e al-Shi'a va Osoolehem va Asma'a al-Mosanefin va Adhab-e al-Osool. Qom: Maktab al-Muhaqiq al-Tabatabai; 1999. p.33 -653. (Full Text in Arabic)
Khoei SA. Mo'ajam al-Rijal-e al-Hadith. Tehran: Bonyad-e Islami al-Khoei; V(1-21): p 22-364. (Full Text in Arabic)
Najashi A. Rijal al-Najashi. Qom: Daftar-e Entesharat-e Islami vabasteh be Jame' Modaresin-e Hovzeh Elmeiye-ye Qom; 1986. p.26-418. (Full Text in Arabic)
Helli H. al-Rijal (Ibn-e Davood). Tehran: University of Tehran Press; 1963. p 28-420. (Full Text in Arabic)
Mamaqhani A. Tanghih al-Maghal fi Elm al-Rijal. Qom: Moasseseh Al al-Bayt Le-Ehya al-Torath V(14 , 31): p 103- 134. (Full Text in Arabic)
Helli H. Rijal al-Alamah al-Helli. Najaf Ashraf: Dar al-Zakhirah; 1990. p 19,270. (Full Text in Arabic)
Tousi M. Rijal al-Tousi. Qom: Daftar-e Entesharat-e Islami vabasteh be Jame' Modaresin Hovzeh Elmeiyeh-e Qom; 1994. p.124-367. (Full Text in Arabic)
Rabbani J. Vaqhefiyah va Andisheye-ye Vaqhefiyah Ba'd az Imam Kazem (PBUH). Qom: Moasseseh Farhangi va Ettela-Resani Tebyan; 2008. p.20. (Full Text in Persian)
Tostari MT. Qamus al-Rijal. 2 ed. Qom: Daftar-e Entesharat-e Islami Vabasteh be Jame'e Modaresin Hovzeh Elmiyeh-e Qom; 1989- 2001. V(2-10): p 56-365. (Full Text in Arabic)
Helli H. Kholaseh Aghval fi Elm-e al-Rijal: Bonyad-e Nashr-e Feqh; 1996. p 428. (Full Text in Arabic)
Barqi A. Rijal al-Barqi-al-Tabaqat. Tehran: University of Tehran Press; 1963. p.28. (Full Text in Arabic)
Kashshi M. Ekhtiar-o Marefat al-Rijal (Rijal al-Kashshi. Correction by Mohammad Ibn Hassan Tousi and Hassan Mostafavi. Mashhad: Mashhad University Publishing Institute; 1988. p 3,130-301. (Full Text in Arabic)
Ibn Ghazairi A. Rijal (Ibn al-Ghazairi). Qom: Dar al-Hadith; 1985. p 40-122. (Full Text in Arabic)
Kashshi M. Ekhtiar-o Marefat al-Rijal (with Comments by Mirdamad al-Astarabadi). Qom: Moasseseh al-Bayt; 1984. V(1): p.10. (Full Text in Arabic)
Abu Ghaleb Zarari A. Resaleh Abu Ghaleb al-Zarari ela Ibn Ibnehi dar Zikr al-A'yan. Qom: Markaz-e Motaleat va Tahghighat-e Islami; 1990. p.34-64 . (Full Text in Arabic)
Sayyed Ibn Tavous A. Falah al-Sael va Najah al-Masael. Qom: Daftar-e Tablighat-e Islami Hovzeh Ilmiyeh Qom; 1986. V(1): p 28, 193. (Full Text in Arabic)
Shahid Sani Z. al-Reayah fi Elm al-Derayah. Tehran: Ketabkhaneh Ayat Allah Mar'ashi Najafi 1987. p.150. (Full Text in Arabic)
al-Ameli M. al-Vajizeh fi Elm al-Derayah. Qom: Basirati; 1970. p.5. (Full Text in Arabic)
Sadr S. Nahayah al-Derayah: Nashr al-Mash'ar; 1935. p.304. (Full Text in Arabic)
Nafisi S. Derayah al-Hadith. Tehran: The Organization for Researching and Composing University Textbooks in the Islamic Sciences and the Humanities (SAMT); 2015. p. 224-228 . (Full Text in Arabic)
Mohammadi Mozafar MH. Weakening and Correction Funds Documents of Ashura pilgrimage. Hadith Science. 2006;11(3):128-44. (Full Text in Persian)
Mehrizi M. Hadith-Pazhuhi. Qom: Moasseseh Elmi
va Farhangi-e Dar-al-Hadith Sazman-e Entesharat; 2011;1:181. (Full Text in Persian)
Mehrizi M, Fathi Akbar-Abadi J. Barresi va Tahlil-e Sanadi-e Ahadith-e Tebi dar Bihar al-Anvar bar Asas-e Mojalad-e 59. Hadith Research. 2017;9(1):193-214. (Full Text in Persian)
- Abstract Viewed: 272 times
- PDF (فارسی) Downloaded: 127 times