Appeals & Complaints Policy

Adhering to the principles of transparency, accountability, and fairness in academic publishing, the Journal of Research on Religion & Health recognizes the right of authors to submit reasoned appeals. Based on the core practices of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), this journal has established an independent and transparent mechanism for investigating scientific appeals and procedural complaints.

1. Appeal Process Against Editorial Decisions (Rejection)

Authors who believe the decision to reject their manuscript resulted from the reviewers' misunderstanding of the research methodology, a blatant calculative error, or the dismissal of key empirical data may appeal subject to the following conditions:

  • Submission Deadline: The appeal request must be sent to the journal office no later than 30 calendar days after the communication of the Editor-in-Chief's decision letter.
  • Structure of Scientific Argument: The appeal letter must contain robust, documented, and point-by-point responses to the reviewers' objections. General complaints, expressions of personal dissatisfaction, or insistence without providing new empirical and statistical evidence will not be considered.
  • Independent and Impartial Review: The Editor-in-Chief will refer the case, along with the complete records of the previous review, to an independent member of the editorial board or a new peer reviewer outside the previous cycle to ensure an impartial re-evaluation.

2. Timeline and Stages of Appeal Handling

Review Stage Response Timeframe Editorial Action and Output
Registration and Acknowledgment of Receipt Up to 3 business days Formal assessment of documents and sending an official confirmation to the corresponding author
Preliminary Evaluation by Editor-in-Chief Up to 7 business days Assessing the validity of arguments and deciding whether to dismiss the claim or refer it to a new reviewer
Independent Re-evaluation 14 to 21 business days Confidential evaluation by an independent editorial board member or impartial peer reviewer
Communication of Final Decision 5 business days Sending the detailed expert report and the definitive outcome to the corresponding author

3. Final Decision Rule (Single Appeal Limit)

There is an opportunity to submit a scientific appeal only once per manuscript. The decision made after the re-evaluation will be final, conclusive, and not subject to further appeal, and the manuscript's file will be officially closed.

4. Complaints Regarding Procedural Performance, Reviewers' Conduct, and Conflict of Interest

Complaints related to unconventional delays, breach of confidentiality, unprofessional behavior of peer reviewers, or conflict of interest among editorial members are investigated separately:

  • Submission Method: Send a formal letter along with supporting documents to the official email of the journal office at jrrh@sbmu.ac.ir.
  • Complaint Against the Editor-in-Chief's Decision: If the subject of the complaint involves the performance of the Editor-in-Chief themselves, to prevent a conflict of interest, the case is referred directly to the Medical Journals Management of Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences (Vice-Chancellor for Research and Technology) as the higher authority.
  • Protection of Complainant's Confidentiality: The identity of the complainants and all correspondence will remain strictly confidential until the end of the investigation process.