Article Withdrawal Policy

Committed to the guidelines of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE), the Journal of Research on Religion and Health has established a specific process for manuscript withdrawal requests. The purpose of this guideline is to safeguard the time and efforts of peer reviewers and the editorial staff, prevent the waste of academic resources, and avoid the simultaneous submission of articles to other journals.

1. Criteria and Procedures for Withdrawal Requests by Authors

Requests for article withdrawal will solely be considered subject to the following conditions:

  • Formal Written Request: The withdrawal request must be submitted as a formal letter stating documented scientific or legal reasons, signed by the corresponding author on behalf of all authors, via the journal's system dashboard or sent to jrrh@sbmu.ac.ir.
  • Prohibition of Simultaneous Submission Until Approval: Until the official letter of approval for withdrawal and the manuscript's removal from the system is issued by the Editor-in-Chief, the manuscript is considered under consideration by the journal. Submitting it to any other journal constitutes academic misconduct and Duplicate Submission.
  • Review of Withdrawal Reasons: If the withdrawal stems from the discovery of a fundamental scientific error in the data, the journal office commends this ethical action by the authors; however, withdrawing to submit to another journal after peer-review time has been expended violates professional publishing ethics.

2. Manuscript Status at Various Stages and Conditions for Withdrawal Acceptance

Manuscript Stage Withdrawal Possibility Financial Status Consequences and Editorial Procedure
Prior to Peer Review (Screening) Allowed No Cost The file is closed without issue, and a withdrawal certificate is issued within 3 working days.
Under Evaluation and Peer Review Conditional upon providing valid reasons Non-refundable review fee The process is halted, and a report of the actions taken is recorded in the authors' history.
After Issuance of Scientific Acceptance Certificate Not Allowed (except in emergencies) Preparation costs penalty Subject to presentation to the Editorial Board and meticulous review of the reasons stated by the authors.
After Online Publication Impossible (Only Retraction or Correction) No refund of fees File deletion is not possible, and in accordance with COPE guidelines, a correction or Retraction will be published.

3. Consequences of Unjustified and Uncoordinated Withdrawal

Unilateral withdrawal after the initiation of the peer review process or the simultaneous submission of the article to other journals without an official withdrawal declaration is considered a blatant ethical violation. Should the abuse of peer reviewers' and editorial staff's time be confirmed, the Editorial Board reserves the right to suspend future submissions by the respective authors for a period of 1 year and report the matter to the research deputyship of the authors' affiliated university.

4. Archiving and Confidentiality of Withdrawn Articles

Manuscripts for which withdrawal is officially approved will have their status changed to "Closed due to withdrawal" in the system. The research files and data will remain strictly confidential with the journal, and no part of the ideas or findings will be published.