Risk-Based Inspection Technique and the Benefits of its Implementation in Improving the Process Management System of Oil, Gas and Petrochemical Industries: A Review Study
Irtiqa Imini Pishgiri Masdumiyat (Safety Promotion and Injury Prevention),
Vol. 8 No. 3 (1399),
16 November 2020
,
Page 171 - 158
https://doi.org/10.22037/meipm.v8i3.31164
Abstract
Background and objectives: In the processing industry, deaths and severe damages to the equipment due to certain incidents were reported in recent years. And, the industrial sectors are interested in an effective means to prevent or reduce the severity of these accidents in an integrated and planned manner. The aim of this study is a risk-based inspection technique and the consequent benefits of its implementation in the process industries.
Materials and Methods: In this retrospective study, keywords related to research title, including risk-based
inspection, risk management, probability of failure, a consequence of failure, risk analysis, process management, risk-based maintenance, corrosion management, process safety, and Asset Integrity management was selected and then searched on the internal and external databases of Science Direct, PubMed, Google Scholar, SID, Google Search, Magiran, Civilica and Scopus without any time limit. Then the findings and results of confirmed research were extracted and analyzed. Finally, conclusions about the benefits of this method in improving the process management system were reviewed. Then the findings and results of confirmed research were extracted and analyzed. Finally, the conclusion about the effect of the advantages of this method in improving the process management system was examined.
Result: A review of various studies showed that the benefits of using RBI were summarized into 11 ategories, including business (economic), effective operations, risk management, effective inspection management, asset and corrosion integrated management, experts of competency and knowledge, health, safety, environment (HSE), compliance with risk and safety standards, process safety, social expectations, legal, and judicial requirements.
Conclusion: The results showed that the use of RBI in the process industry provides many benefits. Therefore, the establishment and implementation of risk-based inspection in these industries can increase the functionality of equipment and improve the process management system.
How to cite this article: Moradi B. Risk-Based Inspection Technique and the Benefits of its Implementation in Improving the Process Management System of Oil, Gas and Petrochemical Industries: A Review Study. J Saf Promot Inj Prev. 2020; 8(3):157-71.
- Risk-Based Inspection (RBI); Risk Management; Maintenance; Asset Integrity; Process Safety
How to Cite
References
Soleimani A, Samavatyan H, Nouri A. The Relationship between Job Security and Organizational Support with the Accidents at the Province of Isfahan’s Gas Company: The Moderating Role of Demographic Factors. Safety Promotion and Injury Prevention. 2017;5(1):15-24.
Jafari MJ, Askarian AR, Omidi L, Lavasani MRM, Taghavi L, Ashori AR. The assessment of independent layers of protection in gas sweetening towers of two gas refineries. Safety promotion and injury prevention (Tehran). 2014;2(2):103-12.
Mohammadi G, Azimi Y, Sarkheil H, Bodaghjamali J. Modeling and Evaluation of the Benzene Leakage Consequences in the Coking Plant of Isfahan Steel Company. Safety Promotion and Injury Prevention. 2019;7(1):10-9.
Zohar D. Thirty years of safety climate research: Reflections and future directions. Accident Analysis & Prevention. 2010;42(5):1517-22.
Khan FI, Abbasi S. Techniques and methodologies for risk analysis in chemical process industries. Journal of loss Prevention in the Process Industries. 1998;11(4):261-77.
Narimisaa MR, Narimisa MR. Technical Inspection Engineering and Risk Based Inspection as index of efficient industrial management system. International Journal Of Advanced Biotechnology And Research. 2017;8(2):472-6.
Ebrahimi Avardklo F VR, Hosseinpour M, Mansouri Serasht, Neqavi C, Ghaemi A. Risk-Based Inspection (RBI) on oil rigs.The first international conference on maintenance and repair in the oil, gas and petrochemical industries, oil company training center, Mahmoud Abad, September 19 and 20. 2013:290-303
Azadeh A, Mohammad Fam I. A framework for development of integrated intelligent human engineering environment. Information Technology Journal. 2006;5(2):290-9.
Chang M-K, Chang R-R, Shu C-M, Lin K-N. Application of risk based inspection in refinery and processing piping. Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries. 2005;18(4-6):397-402.
Ismaeili A, Derlik F, Havashi Nejadian S, editors. Domestication, codification and implementation of RBI strategy in the deethanizer section in the olefin unit of Arya Sasol petrochemical company. Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Oil, Gas and Petrochemicals; 2014.
El-Reedy M. Risk-based inspection technique. Offshore Structures: Design, Construction and Maintenance Oxford: Gulf Professional Publishing. 2012.
kh H. Risk Assessment of Heat Recovery Steam Generator (HRSG) Using RBI Methology.: Universiti Teknologi Petronas; 2017; 63-4.
Holland M. Cost savings achievable through application of risk based inspection philosophies. Risk, Economy and Safety, Failure Minimisation and Analysis. 1998.
Ayele Y, Barabadi A, editors. Risk based inspection of offshore topsides static mechanical equipment in Arctic conditions. 2016 IEEE International Conference on Industrial Engineering and Engineering Management (IEEM); 2016: IEEE.
DNV DN. Recommended Practice DNV-RP-G101: Risk Based Inspection of Offshore Topsides Static Mechanical Equipment. 2010.
API R. 580 Recommended Practice for Risk-Based Inspection. American Petroleum Institute, Washington, DC. 2009.
API R. 580, 2016. Risk-Based Inspection API Recommended Practice. 2016.
Khan F, Rathnayaka S, Ahmed S. Methods and models in process safety and risk management: Past, present and future. Process safety and environmental protection. 2015;98:116-47.
Khan FI, Haddara MM, Bhattacharya SK. Risk‐based integrity and inspection modeling (RBIIM) of process components/system. Risk Analysis: An International Journal. 2006 Feb;26(1):203-21.
American Society of Mechanical Engineers. Inspection planning using risk-based methods. American Society of Mechanical Engineers; 2008.
Wintle JB, Kenzie BW, Amphlett GJ, Smalley S. Best practice for risk based inspection as a part of plant integrity management. Great Britain, Health and Safety Executive; 2001.
Drożyner P, Veith E. Risk based inspection methodology overview. Diagnostyka. 2002;27:82-8.
Khan FI, Sadiq R, Haddara MM. Risk-based inspection and maintenance (RBIM): multi-attribute decision-making with aggregative risk analysis. Process safety and environmental protection. 2004;82(6):398-411.
Inspection RB. API Recommended Practice 580. American Petroleum Institute. 2000.
Khan FI, Haddara MR. Risk-based maintenance of ethylene oxide production facilities. Journal of hazardous materials. 2004;108(3):147-59.
Sweet L, Kaley LC, Valbuena RR, Warnock A. Risk based inspection prioritization applied to an ammonia plant. Ammonia Plant Safety and Related Facilities. 2001;41:147-56.
Peterson R, editor Developing an efficient, predictive, risk based inspection/maintenance program for recovery and power boilers. ASME Pressure Vessels and Piping Conference; 2004.
van der Ven J-K, van Leersum B, van Rij M, Leferink F, editors. Cost-effective electromagnetic compatible installation on ships using a risk based approach. 2017 International Symposium on Electromagnetic Compatibility-EMC EUROPE; 2017: IEEE.
Aguilar–Otero JR, Lopez-Ojeda L. Risk–Based Inspection (RBI), as a tool for managing risks–beyond inspection plans. 2012.
Khan FI, Haddara MM, Bhattacharya SK. Risk‐based integrity and inspection modeling (RBIIM) of process components/system. Risk Analysis: An International Journal. 2006;26(1):203-21.
Murariu A, Paşca N. Application of Risk Based Inspection to heat exchangers of a chemical plant for heavy water production. Welding & Material Testing. 2013;22:9-12.
Rahman RA, Malek MA, Pacific RA, Rahman RA. Safety of machinery and special scheme inspection’s requirement towards industry competitiveness in Malaysia. Mod Appl Sci. 2016 Aug 18;10:211-6.
Tronskar JP, Kaley LC. Benefits of Risk Based Inspection to the Oil and Gas Industry‖. Det Norske Veritas. Singapore; 2000.
Corotis RB, Hugh Ellis J, Jiang M. Modeling of risk-based inspection, maintenance and life-cycle cost with partially observable Markov decision processes. Structure and Infrastructure Engineering. 2005;1(1):75-84.
Fujiyama K, Nagai S, Akikuni Y, Fujiwara T, Furuya K, Matsumoto S, et al. Risk-based inspection and maintenance systems for steam turbines. International Journal of Pressure Vessels and Piping. 2004;81(10-11):825-35.
Bertolini M, Bevilacqua M, Ciarapica FE, Giacchetta G. Development of risk-based inspection and maintenance procedures for an oil refinery. Journal of loss prevention in the process industries. 2009;22(2):244-53.
Kauer R, Jovanovic A, Vage Sa-G, Editors. Plant Asset Manageme Nt Rimap (Risk-Based Inspection And Maintenance For European Industries) The European Approac H. Asme/Jsme 2004 Pressure Vessels And Piping Conference; 2004: American Society Of Mechanical Engineers Digital Collection.
Hashemi SJ, Javadpour S, Peikari M, Zahiri MR, Hashempour S, Mojaradian A, editors. Implementation of risk based inspection methodology in managing integrity of Abadan Refinery pressurized production facilities. ICPIIT 2009; 2009.
Ghaffari Ma Mm, Barqi H, Ramazanpour A. Design Risk Based Inspection Software, Prioritized Inspection Schedule Of Gas City Gate Station. International Conference On Innovation In Science And Technology; Tehran 2016.
API R. 580, 2002. Risk-Based Inspection 1st Edn, American Petroleum Institute, Washington, DC USA. 2002;60.
Nugroho A, Haryadi GD, Ismail R, Kim SJ, editors. Risk based inspection for atmospheric storage tank. AIP Conference Proceedings; 2016: AIP Publishing LLC.
Antony TJ, de Klerk AM, editors. Effectiveness of the Risk Based Inspection process in the Sasol business in South Africa. Proceedings of PICMET’14 Conference: Portland International Center for Management of Engineering and Technology; Infrastructure and Service Integration; 2014: IEEE.
Perumal KE. Corrosion risk analysis, risk based inspection and a case study concerning a condensate pipeline. Procedia Engineering. 2014;86:597-605.
TWI. Risk Based Inspection, 2009 2017 [Available from: https://www.twi-global.com/what-we-do/services-and-support/asset-management/risk-based-inspection.
Selvik JT, Scarf P, Aven T. An extended methodology for risk based inspection planning. Reliability: Theory & Applications. 2011;6(1 (20)).
Straub D, Goyet J, So̸rensen JD, Faber MH, editors. Benefits of risk based inspection planning for offshore structures. 25th International Conference on Offshore Mechanics and Arctic Engineering; 2006: American Society of Mechanical Engineers Digital Collection.
Moradi B, Jazani RK, Gheisvandi H, Tehrani GM. Risks management of Tube Bundle heat exchanger in the petrochemical industries using the Risk-Based Inspection approach. Journal of Health in the Field. 2019;7(1).
Khan FI, Haddara MM. Risk-based maintenance (RBM): a quantitative approach for maintenance/inspection scheduling and planning. Journal of loss prevention in the process industries. 2003;16(6):561-73.
Khan FI, Haddara M, Krishnasamy L. A new methodology for risk-based availability analysis. IEEE Transactions on Reliability. 2008;57(1):103-12.
Akanni J, Alonge O, editors. Effective Implementation of Risk Based Inspection (RBI) Approach in Asset Integrity Management of Oil and Gas Facilities. ASME 2015 Pressure Vessels and Piping Conference; 2015: American Society of Mechanical Engineers Digital Collection.
Medina H, Arnaldos J, Casal J. Risk-based inspection and its application to the optimization of chemical plants. Chemical Engineering Transactions. 2011;25:201-6.
Chen X, Yang T, AI Z, WANG B, GU W. Discussion about several issues in the practice of risk-based inspection (RBI). Pressure Vessel Technology. 2005;7(009).
doo Zagreb M. RISK BASED INSPECTION.
Bragatto P, Delle Site C, Faragnoli A. Opportunities and threats of risk based inspections: The new Italian legislation on pressure equipment inspection. CHEMICAL ENGINEERING. 2012;26.
Ekpiwhre EO, Tee KF. Reliability based maintenance methodology for sustainable transport asset management. Pollack Periodica. 2018;13(1):99-112.
Tien S-W, Hwang W-T, Tsai C-H. Study of a risk-based piping inspection guideline system. ISA transactions. 2007;46(1):119-26.
Reynolds JT. The application of risk-based inspection methodology in the petroleum and petrochemical industry. American Society of Mechanical Engineers, New York, NY (United States); 1996.
Straub D, Faber MH. Computational aspects of risk‐based inspection planning. Computer‐Aided Civil and Infrastructure Engineering. 2006;21(3):179-92.
Zhang M, Liang W, Qiu Z, Lin Y, editors. Application of Risk-Based Inspection method for gas compressor station. Journal of Physics: Conference Series; 2017: IOP Publishing.
Prayogo GS, Haryadi GD, Ismail R, Kim SJ, editors. Risk analysis of heat recovery steam generator with semi quantitative risk based inspection API 581. AIP Conference Proceedings; 2016: AIP Publishing LLC.
Priyanta D, Siswantoro N, Megawan AM. Risk based inspection of gas-cooling heat exchanger. International Journal of Marine Engineering Innovation and Research. 2017;1(4).
Al-Mithin AW, Sardesai V, Al-Harbi B, Hannan ASA, editors. Risk Based Inspection (RBI) of Aboveground Storage Tanks to Improve Asset Integrity. IPTC 2012: International Petroleum Technology Conference; 2012: European Association of Geoscientists & Engineers.
CHEN X-d, AI Z-b, YANG T-c, WANG B, GU W-p. Assessment Method of Failure Probability with Residual Life as Reference in Risk-Based-Inspection (RBI)[J]. Pressure Vessel Technology. 2006;5:1-5.
Shuai J, Han K, Xu X. Risk-based inspection for large-scale crude oil tanks. Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries. 2012;25(1):166-75.
Mohamed R, Che Hassan CR, Hamid MD. Implementing risk‐based inspection approach: Is it beneficial for pressure equipment in Malaysia industries? Process Safety Progress. 2018;37(2):194-204.
Simpson J, editor The application of risk based inspection to pressure vessels and aboveground storage tanks in petroleum fuel refineries. Proceedings of the 5th Australasian Congress on Applied Mechanics; 2007: Engineers Australia.
Jovanovic A. Risk-based inspection and maintenance in power and process plants in Europe. Nuclear Engineering and Design. 2003;226(2):165-82.
Lloyd-Bostock SM, Hutter BM. Reforming regulation of the medical profession: The risks of risk-based approaches. Health, Risk & Society. 2008;10(1):69-83.
Naubnome V, Haryadi GD, Ismail R, Kim SJ, editors. Rısk analysis for pressure vessel with external corrosion using RBI method based on API 581. AIP Conference Proceedings; 2016: AIP Publishing LLC.
Willcocks J, Bai Y, editors. Risk-Based inspection and integrity management of pipeline systems. The Tenth International Offshore and Polar Engineering Conference; 2000: International Society of Offshore and Polar Engineers.
Montgomery RL, Serratella C, editors. Risk-based maintenance: a new vision for asset integrity management. ASME 2002 Pressure Vessels and Piping Conference; 2002: American Society of Mechanical Engineers Digital Collection.
Hassan J, Khan F. Risk-based asset integrity indicators. Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries. 2012;25(3):544-54.
Qiu Q. Risk assessment of power system catastrophic failures and hidden failure monitoring & control system: Virginia Tech; 2003.
Conachey R, Serratella CM, Wang G. Risk-based strategies for the next generation of maintenance and inspection programs. WMU Journal of Maritime Affairs. 2008;7(1):151-73.
Tan Z, Li J, Wu Z, Zheng J, He W. An evaluation of maintenance strategy using risk based inspection. Safety science. 2011;49(6):852-60.
Bharadwaj UR, Silberschmidt VV, Wintle JB. A risk based approach to asset integrity management. Journal of Quality in Maintenance Engineering. 2012.
Singh M, Markeset T. A methodology for risk-based inspection planning of oil and gas pipes based on fuzzy logic framework. Engineering Failure Analysis. 2009;16(7):2098-113.
Palacios CA, editor Risk Based Corrosion Management System for Oilfield Production Installations-Development, Methodology and Application. CORROSION 2003; 2003: NACE International.
Kishawy HA, Gabbar HA. Review of pipeline integrity management practices. International Journal of Pressure Vessels and Piping. 2010;87(7):373-80.
API R-BIM. API Recommended Practice 581. American Petroleum Institute; 2016.
Mohamed R, Che Hassan CR, Hamid MD. Critical success factors of risk‐based inspection. Process Safety Progress. 2019;38(1):4-20.
Ablitt C, Speck J, editors. Experiences in implementing risk-based inspection. 3rd MENDT-Middle East Nondesctructive Testing Conference,(November 2005), Bahrain; 2005.
Pursell MJ, Selman C, Nielsen MF, editors. Corrosion Risk Assessment and Risk Based Inspection for Sweet Oil and Gas Corrosion-Practical Experience. CORROSION 99; 1999: NACE International.
Mediansyah G, Haryadi RI, SJ K, editors. Risk Analysis of Central Java Gas Transmission Pipeline by Risk-Based Inspection Method. Proceedings of the The 4th International Conference on Advanced Materials Science and Technology; 2016.
Reynolds JT. Risk-based inspection improves safety of pressure equipment. Oil and Gas Journal;(United States). 1995;93(3).
Dou Z, Jiang J-C, Wang Z-R, Pan X-H, Shu C-M, Liu L-F. Applications of RBI on leakage risk assessment of direct coal liquefaction process. Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries. 2017;45:194-202.
LI D-b, XIE G-s, LI Z-f. Risk Based Inspection Analysis and Reducing Risk Suggestion in Fluid Catalytic Cracking Unit [J]. Petro-Chemical Equipment. 2010;4.
Tammer M, Kaminski ML, editors. Fatigue oriented risk based inspection and structural health monitoring of FPSOs. The Twenty-third International Offshore and Polar Engineering Conference; 2013: International Society of Offshore and Polar Engineers.
Rathnayaka S, Khan F, Amyotte P. Risk-based process plant design considering inherent safety. Safety science. 2014;70:438-64.
Khan F, Abunada H, John D, Benmosbah T. Development of risk‐based process safety indicators. Process Safety Progress. 2010;29(2):133-43.
Straub D, Malioka V, Faber MH. A framework for the asset integrity management of large deteriorating concrete structures. Structure and Infrastructure Engineering. 2009;5(3):199-213.
Race JM. Management of corrosion of onshore pipelines. InShreir’s Corrosion: Management and Control of Corrosion 2009 Dec 7 (pp. 3270-3306).
Dey PK, Ogunlana SO, Naksuksakul S. Risk‐based maintenance model for offshore oil and gas pipelines: a case study. Journal of Quality in Maintenance Engineering. 2004.
ZHENG M, YAO A-l, YE C, KANG L, LAN G-g, TANG Y. Study on risk assessment method of separator in gas station based on RBI [J]. Journal of Safety Science and Technology. 2013;6.
Bashor CBC, editor Reducing the Risk of Aboveground Storage Tank Floor Leaks. Minnesota Pollution Control Agency, Freshwater Spills Symposium, Cleveland, Ohio; 2002.
Raouf A, Duffuaa S, Ben‐Daya M, Dhillon B, Liu Y. Human error in maintenance: a review. Journal of quality in maintenance engineering. 2006.
Noroozi A, Khakzad N, Khan F, MacKinnon S, Abbassi R. The role of human error in risk analysis: Application to pre-and post-maintenance procedures of process facilities. Reliability Engineering & System Safety. 2013;119:251-8.
Noroozi A, Khan F, MacKinnon S, Amyotte P, Deacon T. Determination of human error probabilities in maintenance procedures of a pump. Process Safety and Environmental Protection. 2014;92(2):131-41.
ABS. Guide for surveys using risk-based inspection for the offshore industry. American Bureau of Shipping Houston (TX; 2003.
Bos M. ICAF 2009, Bridging the Gap Between Theory and Operational Practice: Proceedings of the 25th Symposium of the International Committee on Aeronautical Fatigue, Rotterdam, the Netherlands, 27-29 May 2009: Springer Science & Business Media; 2009.
Ibragimov S, Taymetov B. “To Permit or Not to Permit”—Tools for Reforming Permits and Licensing Systems. 2007.
Smalley AJ, Mauney DA, editors. Risk Based Maintenance Of Turbomachinery. Proceedings of the 26th Turbomachinery Symposium; 1997: Texas A&M University. Turbomachinery Laboratories.
Black J. Risk-based Regulation. 2010.
Bhandari J, Arzaghi E, Abbassi R, Garaniya V, Khan F. Dynamic risk‐based maintenance for offshore processing facility. Process Safety Progress. 2016;35(4):399-406.
Márquez AC, de León PM, Rosique AS, Fernández JFG. Criticality analysis for maintenance purposes. Advanced Maintenance Modelling for Asset Management: Springer; 2018. p. 143-66.
Institute AP. Risk-based Inspection: API Recommended Practice 580: Downstream Segment: American Petroleum Institute; 2002.
Bier VM. Challenges to the acceptance of probabilistic risk analysis. Risk Analysis. 1999;19(4):703-10.
Wang G, Yan T, Zhang J, Chen J. Risk Based Inspection on the equipment of low density polyethylene. Procedia Engineering. 2011;15:1145-8.
Britton CF. Corrosion monitoring and inspection. InMicrobiology in Civil Engineering 1990 Aug 30 (pp. 382-390). CRC Press.
Roberge PR. Corrosion inspection and monitoring: John Wiley & Sons; 2007.
- Abstract Viewed: 893 times