Challenge with Medicine (A Glance at the Battle between Superstition and Medicine in Iran from 1200 to 1800 AD with Reference to Three Pieces of Persian Writing)
Tārīkh-i pizishkī i.e., Medical History,
Vol. 10 No. 37 (1397),
3 December 2019
,
Page 31-41
https://doi.org/10.22037/mhj.v10i37.24414
Abstract
Background and Aim: The prevalence of superstition became widespread in Iran, especially after the Mongol invasion in the seventh century AH and expanded from religious to scientific domains. In the meantime, the knowledge of medicine was subject to superstition more than other sciences and various works and books were written on the subject of the sciences of strangers or medical professionals. In this article, we have tried to analyze the methods and tools as well as the morphology of these medical superstitions based on three Persian manuscripts, which have been compiled between the ninth and twelfth centuries.
Materials and Methods: This research is a documentary study. In addition to historical books, three Persian-Arabic manuscripts have been used in this study: Two manuscripts are kept in the Turkish Nuruosmaniye library and one is kept in the library of the Islamic parliament in Iran.
Findings: This study shows that the most important causes of the spread of medical superstitions are: Unfamiliarity with the main causes of disease, trying to Ineffectively Show Medicine and cultural, social and economic disruptions. The overall structure of superstitions is based on: Using obscure titles and words, Inducing and using words in a specific way, the use of numbers and letters in a particular time and place and trying to gain the trust and confidence of the audience.
Conclusion: An examination of the similarities and general structure of superstitious medical beliefs shows that these superstitions focus on "simulation". Proponents of superstitions have sought to actualize their beliefs by making similarities between superstitions and religious beliefs - especially for women and children and gradually introduce superstitions as metaphysical alternatives to experimental medical methods.
Please cite this article as: Mojarrad M. Challenge with Medicine a Glance at the Battle between Superstition and Medicine in Iran from 1200 to 1800 AD with Reference to Three Pieces of Persian Writing). Med Hist J 2019; 10(37): 31-41.
- Medicine, Superstition, Persian Manuscript, Tohfat al-Gharayeb, Occult Science
How to Cite
References
Kulayni AJM. Al-Kafi. Achievement Department of Heritage Revival Research Center Dar al-Hadith. Qom: Dar al-Hadith; 2008. Vol.1 p.23-71. [Arabic]
Asqalani IH. Bazl al-Ma'a'un fi al-Ta'a'un. The Turkish Copirli Library, dated at 1492, Manuscript No.255, folium 4A-4B; 1492. [Arabic]
Abdul Jabbar AAJ. Prophets of prophecy. Achieved and Presented to him by Othman AK. Beirut: Dar al-Arabiya for Printing, Publishing and Distribution; No Date. Vol.2 p.631, 633-645. [Arabic]
Saadi AMM. Bostan Sa'adi (Saadi letter). Corrected and Explained by Yousefi GH-H. Tehran: Kharazmi Publications; 2005. p.139. [Persian]
Safi FA. Latȃyef al-Tawaef. Translated by Golchin Me'ani A. Tehran: Iqbal Publications; 1988. p.205-207. [Persian]
Safa Z. History of Iranian Literature in Iran. Tehran: Ferdows Publications; 1990. Vol.3 p.49-50, 103. [Persian]
Edalat A. The Catastrophe Hypothesis: The Lasting Impact of the Mongolian Tragedy on Iran's Political. Social and Scientific History 2010; 77-78: 235-245. [Persian]
Gachik A. An overview on Islamic Manuscripts. Translated by Ansari N. Tehran: Library and Information Science Research Institute; 1989. Vol.14 p.5-12. [Persian]
Marashi SM. An Overview on the Manuscripts. Miras Shahab 2010; 59: 3-30. [Persian]
Anonymous. Collection of Treatises, Manuscript No.957, folium: 30B, 34B, 35 A, folium: 29b-30a, folium: 30a, folium: 30b, folium: 30b, folium: 30a, folium: 31b. Istanbul: Reserved in the Library of the Osmania Glory of Turkey; No Date. [Persian]
Anonymous. Treatise on the science of strangers, Manuscript No.16509, folium: 5A, folium: 6B, 7A, folium: 5b, 39b, folium: 6b-7a, folium: 7b, 8b, folium: 19a-19b, folium: 48b, folium: 28b, folium: 36a-36b, folia: 20a-30b, folia: 17a-26a. Tehran: Reserved in the Library of the Islamic Consultative Assembly of Iran; No Date. [Persian]
Shojaa Shirazi S. Anis al-Nas "Human Lover". Edited by Afshar I. Tehran: Translation and Publishing Company; 1976. p.218-227. [Persian]
Dehkhoda AA. Amthalwa Hikam "Proverbs and Verdicts". Tehran: Amir Kabir Publications; 2004. Vol.1 p.459, 551; Vol.2 700, Vol.4 p.919-922, 1007. [Persian]
Amoli SH. Nafais al-Fonon fi Arais al-Oyun. Tehran: Islamiye Publications; 2002. Vol.3 p.211. [Persian]
Holy Quran. Al-Jen: 1-15.
Herawi M. Tohfat al-Gharayeb "Masterpiece of Strange", folium: 13a-13b, folium: 44b, folium: 13a, Manuscript No.2848. Istanbul: Reserved in the Library of the Noor Osmania of Turkey; 1737. [Persian]
Fayoumi S S. The Numerical Miracles in the Holy Quran. Cairo: Maktaba al-Ghodsi; 2006. [Arabic]
Ravandi M. Tarikh Ejtemai Iran "Iranian Social History". Tehran: Negah Publications; 1999. Vol.8 p.625-630. [Persian]
- Abstract Viewed: 412 times
- PDF (فارسی) Downloaded: 216 times