Civil liability caused by COVID 19 vaccination
Medical Figh,
Vol. 13 No. 43 (1400),
23 June 2021
,
Page 1-17
https://doi.org/10.22037/mfj.v13i43.34522
Abstract
Background and Aim: Infectious and viral diseases sometimes progress in society so much that special approaches such as general vaccination are considered to control them; because the vaccine, in addition to its preventive and causal properties in promoting health and community development, has a rapid effectiveness on the protection of human life. One of the characteristics of the vaccine used in national immunization programs is its safty. But sometimes, in addition to side effects, they have severe reactions, even with a very low prevalence. This article examines the harms of COVID 19 vaccine injection and proves civil liability in this feild on a jurisprudential basis.
Materials and Methods: The present descriptive and analytical study examines the conditions for the realization of harms due to the COVID 19 vaccine and the civil liability in this field and evaluates the civil liability against the harms caused by the injection of this vaccine based on library sources.
Conclusion: According to the theory of respect, which has the support of Qur'an and Hadith and emphasizes the sanctity of the health of individuals and its importance, as well as the impermissibility of violating the others rights, the right to health should not be ignored. So the warranty against losses due to COVID-19 vaccine has been proven and according to the observations and the samples indicating the damage caused by vaccine injection, in addition to accurate subject matter, as the case may be, vaccine discoverer, vaccine manufacturer, the government as its importer, and any person or organization that has caused the vaccine program to fail and caused harm at any stage, is recognized as responsible and must incur the loss himself or with the help of insurance through Arsh or Diyat.
- Civil Liability; Vaccine ;COVID 19.
How to Cite
References
Zhu, N and others. A Novel Coronavirus from Patients with Pneumonia in China, 2019. The New England Journal of Medicine; 2020. 382. 727. [In English]
Ghotbi, B and Navkhasi, S and Ghobadi, Sh and Shahsavari, Z and Kahrizi, N A review of the Novel Corona Virus Disease. Journal of Health Researc; 2021 (1399). 5 (3). 182. [In Persian]
Naẓarpour, H. Jurisprudential study of civil liability in robotic technology. (Ph.D. Thesis). Babolsar: Mazandaran University; 2021 (1399). 15. [In Persian]
World Health Organization. Vaccine Health Basics-Educational Textbook. Translated by Seyed Mohsen Zahraei, Susan Mahmoudi, Parisa Hedayi, Parviz Vazirian, Fatemeh Abdoli Yaghini, Tehran: Mojasame; 2016 (1394). 275. [In Persian]
https://www.fda.gov.ir/fa. [In Persian]
National Committee of COVID-19 Vaccine. Guide to making Covid-19 vaccine from research and development to market entry-Regulatory Requirements. Tehran: Food and Drug Organization of the Ministry of Health and Medical Education; 2021 (1399). 10, 11-14. [In Persian]
Najafi khansari, M. Resalat Ghaʿdat La ḍarar. Tehran: Mohammadiat Library; 1954 (1373). 199, 219. [In Arabic]
Khoī, A. Mesbah al-fiqahat. n.p: n.pn; n.d. 3: 195. [In Arabic]
Sobḥani Tabrizy, J. al-rasaʾl al-arbʿ. Qom: imam şadiq Institute; 1994 (1415). 2: 59. [In Arabic]
Bariklo, A. Civil Liability. Tehran: Mizan; 2011 (1389). 62, 131, 132. 46, 50, 51. [In Persian]
Katuzian, N. Non-contractual requirements. Tehran: University of Tehran. 1996 (1374). 1: 48. [In Persian]
Qasimzadeh, M. Obligations and civil liability without a contract. Tehran: Mizan; 2012 (1390). 84, 32, 35. [In Persian]
Hosyny Nizhad, H. Civil Liability. Tehran: Majd; 2011 (1389). 76. [In Persian]
Hashemi, A. the scope of civil liability. Tehran: Imam Sadegh University; 2016 (1394). 22. [In Persian]
Katuzian, N. Legal Events - Civil Liability. Tehran: stock company of Enteshar; 2016 (1394). 49, 79, 16. [In Persian]
Ibn Babeveih, M. Man La Yahḍoroh al-faqih. Qom: Islamic Publications Office; 1992 (1413). 3: 233, 4: 47. [In Arabic]
Kolyny, M. al-kafi. Qom: Dar al-ḥadith; 2008 (1429). 10:476, 14: 480, 10: 284, 4:88. [In Arabic]
Towsi, M. Tahdhib al-aḥkam. Tehran: Dar al-kotob al-islamiat; 1987 (1407). 7: 146, 9: 180. [In Arabic]
Hilli, M. Iḍaḥ al-fawaʾd fi Sharḥ e Moshkilat al-qawaʾd. Qom: Ismaʿilian; 1968 (1387). 2: 48. [In Arabic]
Moḥaqeq damad, M. Qawaʿd e Fiqh. Tehran: Islamic Sciences Publishing Center; 1986 (1406). 1: 150. [In Persian]
Maraghi, A. al-ʿnawin al-fiqhiat. Qom: Islamic Publications Office; 1996 (1417). 1: 317 – 320, 2: 434. [In Arabic]
Naraqy, A. awaʾd al-ayam fi Bayan e qawaʾd al-aḥkam. Qom: Islamic Publications Office; 1997 (1417). 55. [In Arabic]
Khansary, A. Jami al-madarik fi Sharḥ e Mokhtasar al-nafʿ. Qom: Ismaʿilian Institute; 1985 (1405). 5: 192. [In Arabic]
Touny, A. al-Wafiat fi Osoul al-fiqh. Qom: Majma ʿ al-fikr al-islamiat; 1995 (1415). 193. [In Arabic]
Tabatabaī yazdy, M K. Takmelat al-ʿrwat al-wothqa. Qom: Davary; 1993 (1414). 1: 75. [In Arabic]
Sadr, M B. Qaʿdih La ḍarar wa La ḍerar. Qom: Dar al-şadiqin; 1999 (1420). 311. [In Arabic]
Khoī, A. al-hidayat fi al-osoul. Qom: şahib al-amr Institute; 1996 (1417). 3: 574. [In Arabic]
https://www.eghtesadonline.com/n/2Zl3. [In Persian]
https://per.euronews.com/2021/03/15. [In Persian]
mehrnews.com/xV777. [In Persian]
https://www.thehindubusinessline.com/news/science/ covid 19-13-people-in-israel-develop-facial-paralysis-after-getting-vaccinated/article33598635.ece. [In English]
The Holy Qurʾan. Translated by: Ansarian, H. 2: 194. 42: 40. [In Arabic]
Hor Amili, M. Wasaʾl al-shiʿat. Qom: al-albayt Institute; 1989 (1409). 29: 247, 19: 310. [In Arabic]
Makarem shirazi, N. al-qawaʿed al-fiqhiat. Qom: imam Ali School; 1991 (1411). 2: 202. [In Arabic]
Badini, H. Philosophy of Civil Liability. Tehran: stock company of Enteshar; 2006 (1384). 305 -307, 332. [In Persian]
Qasimzadeh, M. Fundamentals of Civil Liability. Tehran: Mizan; 2009 (1387). 324, 327. [In Persian]
Hikmatnia, M. Fundamentals of Civil Liability in Imamia Jurisprudence - Basics and structure. Qom: Institute of Islamic Culture and Thought; 2011 (1389). 207. [In Persian]
Houshmand Firouzabadi, H. Evaluating the jurisprudential principles of civil liability. Journal of the Teachings of Civil Jurisprudence; 2020 (1398). (11): 19. 301, 305. [In Persian]
Qazwyny, A. Yanabiʿ al-aḥkam fi Maʿrifat al-ḥalal wa al-ḥaram. Qom: Islamic Publications Office; 2003 (1424). 2: 630. [In Arabic]
Bojnordy, H. al-qawaʿed al-fiqhiat. Qom: al-hadi; 1998 (1419). 2: 106, 7: 116. [In Arabic]
Jazayery, M. Hoda al-ṭalib fi Sharḥ al-makasib. Qom: Institute of Dar Al-ketab; 1995 (1416). 3: 218. [In Arabic]
Sadr, M. Mawaraʾ al-fiqh. Beirut: Dar Al-azwa; 1999 (1420). 3: 290. [In Arabic]
Baḥrany, Y. al-hadaʾeg al-naḍirat fi Aḥkam al-eʿtrat al-ṭahirat. Qom: Islamic Publications Office; 1985 (1405). 19: 459. [In Arabic]
Najafi, M H. Jawahir al-kalam fi Sharḥ e Sharayeʿ l-islam. Beirut: Dar Ehya Al-torath Al-arabi; 1984 (1404). 24: 265. [In Arabic]
Rahpeik, H. Civil Liability Rights An compensations. Tehran: Khorsandi; 2014 (1392). 53. [In Persian]
Katozian, N. Civil law in the current legal order. Tehran: Mizan; 2018 (1396). 267. [In Persian]
Marʿashy Najafi, Sh. Minhaj al-moʾminin. Qom: Ayatollah Marʿashy Najafi Library Publications; 1986 (1406). 2: 279. [In Arabic]
Khomeiny, R. Zobdat al- Aḥkam. Tehran: Islamic Development Organization; 1984 (1404). 234. [In Arabic]
https://bahjat.ir/fa/ahkam/8780. [In Persian]
http://lankarani.com/far/bok/view.php?ntx=038021 #460. [In Persian]
https://makarem.ir/main.aspx?typeinfo=21&lid=0 &catid=639&mid=260869. [In Persian]
https://noorihamedani.ir/term/category?id=607& sub=3083. [In Persian]
http://www.ghavanin.ir/detail.asp?id=3691. 3713. [In Persian]
Wahdati Shobyry, H. The Basis and Realm of the Damage Surplus to Blood Money. Journal of Figh and Usul, 2011 (1390). (43) 2. 257. [In Persian]
Shojaʿpourian, S. Civil liability Caused by a doctor's error. Tehran: Ferdowsi; 1995 (1373). 29. [In Persian]
Jamalizadeh, A. Jurisprudential review of insurance contract. Qom: Boustan e Ketab; 2002 (1380). 121. [In Persian]
Abbaslou, B. Civil liability. Tehran: Mizan; 2011 (1390). 150. [In Persian]
www.irna.ir/news/84221892. [In Persian]
Zargoush, M. Government civil liability. Tehran: Mizan; 2010 (1389). 2: 107, 124-126. [In Persian]
http://vrc.sbmu.ac.ir/index.jsp?pageid=50586&p=1. [In Persian]
Vice Chancellor for Health Affairs of Shahid Beheshti University. Vaccine side effects instructions. Tehran: Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences and Health and Medical Services; n. D. 14. [In Persian]
- Abstract Viewed: 1111 times
- pdf (فارسی) Downloaded: 78 times