Civil Liability for False Advertising In the Iranian and American Legal Systems with Emphasis on Moral Principles
Akhlāq-i zīstī i.e., Bioethics Journal,
Vol. 11 No. 36 (1400),
17 Mordad 2021
,
Page 1-20
https://doi.org/10.22037/bioeth.v11i36.36270
Abstract
Background and Aim: Today, advertising has a wide influence and an important place in economic and social systems. Despite the benefits of advertising for consumers in terms of creating awareness, manufacturers and distributors as well as advertising industry actors in terms of business prosperity and the media and governments in terms of financial strength and economic promotion, there are also serious harms to the advertising industry, of which false advertising is a prime example. The purpose of this study is to explain the ethical and legal principles governing advertising from the perspective of false advertising and to express the principles of civil liability resulting from false advertising in the Iranian and American legal systems.
Materials and Methods: The present research is done in a descriptive-analytical method by using library (documentary) resources.
Ethical Considerations: Principles related to research ethics have been observed in terms of fidelity in quoting texts and preserving the originality of the article.
Findings: No Harm, maintaining customer independence, fairness, honesty, respect and transparency are among the important ethical and legal principles on how to deal with false advertising. False advertising has been considered in the Iranian and American legal systems, along with scattered laws and regulations. In the discussion of civil liability, the place of general rules is more prominent in both legal systems, especially in consumer protection. Under US law, the Federal Trade Commission and judicial precedents have played an active role in regulating, interpreting, and prosecuting civil liability claims arising from advertising. The basis of civil liability arising from false advertising is affected by the nature of the advertisement, the position of the advertiser (orderer, creator and publisher) and the contractual or noncontractual approach to liability. In order to prove the civil liability arising from advertising, a harmful act (committing one of the examples of false advertising) and a loss due to it are necessary.
Conclusion: The spread of false advertising, in addition to directly harming the customers, leads to major moral and cultural damage, especially the loss of public trust. The mechanism of the civil liability system (including regulation and decisive implementation) can help to prevent immorality and violations in this area by considering the ethical and legal principles surrounding advertising. In the legal system of Iran and the United States, it can be said that the basis of civil liability of the person ordering the advertisement (business owner) for making a false statement that has caused loss, is pure liability or at least a presumption of fault. Advertising creators and publishers are also responsible in case of fault (if proving that they know the information was untrue or typically were known). The need for coherence and legislative integration is evident in both the Iranian and American legal systems.
Cite this article as: Hosseini Nasab A, Almasi NA, Amini M, Nategh Nouri S. Civil Liability for False Advertising In the Iranian and American Legal Systems with Emphasis on Moral Principles. Majale "Akhlāq-i zīstī" (i.e., Bioethics Journal). 2021; 11(36): e17.
- False Advertising; Moral Principles; Civil Liability; Iranian Law; American Law
How to Cite
References
Jafari Tabar H. Civil Liability of Manufacturers and Sellers of Goods. First Edition. Tehran: Dadgostar Publishing; 1996. [Persian]
Ismaili M. Commercial Advertising Law in Iran and the World. First Edition. Tehran: Shahr Publishing; 2007. [Persian]
Motamednejad K. Commercial Advertising Law. First Edition. Tehran: Office of Media Studies and Development; 2009. [Persian]
Ansari B, Mehdizadeh M, Tila P, Shaykh al-Islami Kendalusi J. Civil Liability of Mass Media. 1st ed. Tehran: Presidential deputy for Codification, Revision and Dissemination of Laws and Regulations; 2002. [Persian]
Mostafa Montaghami F. An Introduction to Business Ethics and Advertising in E-Commerce from the Perspective of Consumer Protection. Business Reviews. 2009; 1(40): 21-39. [Persian]
Jafari Barzian F. A Comparative Study of Civil Liability Due to Advertising of Goods in Iranian and British Law. Master Thesis in Private Law. Qom: Qom University; 2010. [Persian]
Khorsandian MA, Chitsaz F. Fundamentals of Responsibility Arising from Commercial Advertising. Quarterly Journal of Private Law Studies. 2015; 45(2): 165-185. [Persian]
Aadel M, Shamsollahi M. Civil liability for false advertisement. Comparative Law Review. 2016; 7(2): 569-599. [Persian]
BeVier LR. Competitor Suits for False Advertising Under Section 43 (a) of the Lanham Act: A Puzzle in the Law of Deception. Va. L. Rev. 1992; 78(1): 1-48.
Huston J. Liability for Commercial Speech: A Guide to False Advertising, Commercial Disparagement and Related Claims. USA: Foley Hoag LLP; 2015.
Kurnit R, Taylor H. Advertising & Marketing in the USA. 2019. Available at: https://www.lexology.com/ library/detail.aspx?g=9fd41625-bced-4bcb-9d3c-96da bf86b673
Klass G. False Advertising Law and New Private Law. Georgetown University Law Center. False Advertising Law, in Oxford Handbook of New Private Law (Andrew Gold et al. eds., Oxford Univ. Pr. forthcoming). Oxford: Oxford University; 2020.
Jabbaran MM. Convergence of bioethics principles in the field of research with Islamic approach. Quarterly Journal of Ethics. 2018; 11(41): 89-106. [Persian]
Sadeghpour M. Criminal Liability Due to Advertising Method. Master Thesis in Criminal Law and Criminology. Qom: Qom University; 2010.
Makarim Shirazi N. Jurisprudence. Part One. Qom: School of Imam Ali Ibn Abi Talib (peace be upon him); 2006. [Arabic]
U.s. Trademark Law. Federal Statutes. U. S. Patent & Trademark Office. 2013.
Jaberi E. Consumer Rights. 1st ed. Tehran: Dadiar Publishing; 2007. [Persian]
Sheikh Ansari M. Makaseb. with the comments of Mohammad Kalantar. Qom: Dar al-Kitab; 2015. Vol.4 p.160.
Khomeini R. Makaseb Muharrameh. Tehran: Institute for Organizing and Publishing the Works of Imam Khomeini; 1994. Vol.2 p.115.
Ismaili M, Rai Tehrani H. Draft Bill of Commercial Advertising Law. Tehran: Institute of Culture, Art and Communication; 2013. p.103.
Federal Trade Commission 16 CFR Part 255. Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising. Available at: https://www.ftc.gov.
Federal Trade Commission Act. Federal Trade Commission. Protecting America's Consumers. Available at: https://www.ftc.gov/enforcement/statutes/ federal-trade-commission-act.
Hosseini Nejad H. Civil Liability. First Edition. Tehran: Jihad University Press of Shahid Beheshti University; 1991. p.70.
Lorasa M. Civil Liability. Translated by Ashtari M. 1st ed. Tehran: Lawyer Publishing; 1996. p.40. [Persian]
Jafari Tabar H. Civil Liability of Goods. Tehran: Dadgostar Publishing; 2010. p.50-52. [Persian]
Baez BI. Tort Law in the USA. New York: Kluwer Law International; 2010. p.270.
Jordan ER, Rubin PH. An economic analysis of the law of false advertising. The Journal of Legal Studies. 1979; 8(3): 527-553.
Perritt JR-HH. Tort liability, the First Amendment, and equal access to electronic networks. Harv. JL & Tech. 1991; 5(1): 65.
Bakhtiarvand M, Agha Mohammadi A. Comparative Business Advertising. Bi-Quarterly Encyclopedia of Economic Law. 2015; 22(8): 97-123.
Katuzian N. Non-Contractual Obligations; Civil Liability. General Rules. Tehran: Institute of Publishing and Printing, University of Tehran; 2008. Vol.1.
- Abstract Viewed: 626 times
- PDF (فارسی) Downloaded: 284 times