ISSN: 1735-1308
Instant 2021
Transperitoneal Laparoscopic Pyelolithotomy versus Percutaneous Nephrolithotomy for Treating the Patients with Staghorn Kidney Stones: A Randomized Clinical Trial
Urology Journal,
,
23 February 2021
,
Page 6831
https://doi.org/10.22037/uj.v18i.6831
Abstract
Purpose: To compare the performance and outcomes of laparoscopic pyelolithotomy (LPL) versus percutaneous nephrolithotomy (PCNL) in the management of staghorn kidney stones.
Materials and Methods: This study was a parallel-group randomized clinical trial study carried out on 68 patients with staghorn stones (one single piece or maximally two-piece stones with large extra renal part) over 18 years referred to Labbafinejhad Hospital. Patients were randomly divided on a ratio of 1:1 into two groups of LPL and PCNL using random allocation software. The primary outcome was the stone free rate, which was evaluated with KUB, and ultrasonography. Secondary outcomes were duration of surgery, bleeding, fever, post-operative pain, length of hospital stay, and postoperative complications.
Results: The mean±SD age of patients in PCNL and LPL groups were 48.50 ± 13.33 years and 52.17 ± 15.74 years, respectively (P=.303). LPL was associated with a higher duration of surgery (196.55 ± 26.58 minutes versus 110.88 ± 34.82; P=.001). Hemoglobin drop in the PCNL group was higher than the LPL group (2.67 ± 2.61 g/dL versus -0.7912 ± 1.06 g/dL; P=.001). Stone free status was observed in 29 (85.3%) patients in the LPL group, which was significantly higher than the PCNL group (22 patients, 64.7%; P =.050).
Conclusion: The results of this study indicate that LPL offers a higher stone free rate with less bleeding in patients with single particle or limited particles staghorn stones with extrarenal pelvis but is associated with a higher duration of operation. The application of LPL in patients with multiple stones carries a lower achievement and is not encouraged.
- laparoscopy; percutaneous nephrolithotomy; pyelolithotomy; staghorn stone
How to Cite
References
Erbagci A, Erbagci AB, Yilmaz M, Yagci F, Tarakcioglu M, Yurtseven C, et al. Pediatric urolithiasis. Scandinavian journal of urology and nephrology. 2003;37(2):129-33.
Pearle MS, Lotan Y. Urinary lithiasis: etiology, epidemiology, and pathogenesis. Campbell-walsh urology. 2007;2:1363-92.
Koga S, Arakaki Y, Matsuoka M, Ohyama C. Staghorn Calculi—Long‐term Results of Management. British journal of urology. 1991;68(2):122-4.
Blandy JP, Singh M. The case for a more aggressive approach to staghorn stones. The Journal of urology. 1976;115(5):505-6.
Heimbach D, Jacobs D, Müller S, Hesse A. Chemolitholysis and lithotripsy of infectious urinary stones–an in vitro study. Urologia internationalis. 2002;69(3):212-8.
Parks JH, Worcester EM, Coe FL, Evan AP, Lingeman JE. Clinical implications of abundant calcium phosphatein routinely analyzed kidney stones. Kidney international. 2004;66(2):777-85.
Basiri A, Kashi AH, Zeinali M, Nasiri MR, Valipour R, Sarhangnejad R. Limitations of Spinal Anesthesia for Patient and Surgeon During Percutaneous Nephrolithotomy. Urology journal. 2018;15(4):164-7.
Al-Kohlany KM, Shokeir AA, Mosbah A, Mohsen T, Shoma AM, Eraky I, et al. Treatment of complete staghorn stones: a prospective randomized comparison of open surgery versus percutaneous nephrolithotomy. The Journal of urology. 2005;173(2):469-73.
Chibber PJ. Percutaneous nephrolithotomy for large and staghorn calculi. Journal of endourology. 1993;7(4):293-5.
Basiri A, Nouralizadeh A, Kashi AH, Radfar MH, Nasiri MR, Zeinali M, et al. X-Ray Free Minimally Invasive Surgery for Urolithiasis in Pregnancy. Urology journal. 2016;13(1):2496-501.
Chang DT, Dretler SP. Laparoscopic pyelolithotomy in an ectopic kidney. The Journal of urology. 1996;156(5):1753-.
Hoenig DM, Shalhav AL, Elbahnasy AM, McDougall EM, Clayman RV. Laparoscopic pyelolithotomy in a pelvic kidney: a case report and review of the literature. JSLS: Journal of the Society of Laparoendoscopic Surgeons. 1997;1(2):163.
Lee JW, Cho SY, Jeong CW, Yu J, Son H, Jeong H, et al. Comparison of surgical outcomes between laparoscopic pyelolithotomy and percutaneous nephrolithotomy in patients with multiple renal stones in various parts of the pelvocalyceal system. Journal of laparoendoscopic & advanced surgical techniques Part A. 2014;24(9):634-9.
Simforoosh N, Radfar MH, Valipour R, Dadpour M, Kashi AH. Laparoscopic Pyelolithotomy for the Management of Large Renal Stones with Intrarenal Pelvis Anatomy. Urology journal. 2020;18(1):40-4.
Maghsoudi R, Etemadian M, Kashi AH, Mehravaran K. Management of Colon Perforation During Percutaneous Nephrolithotomy: 12 Years of Experience in a Referral Center. Journal of endourology. 2017;31(10):1032-6.
el-Nahas AR, Eraky I, Shokeir AA, Shoma AM, el-Assmy AM, el-Tabey NA, et al. Factors affecting stone-free rate and complications of percutaneous nephrolithotomy for treatment of staghorn stone. Urology. 2012;79(6):1236-41.
Kyriazis I, Panagopoulos V, Kallidonis P, Özsoy M, Vasilas M, Liatsikos E. Complications in percutaneous nephrolithotomy. World journal of urology. 2015;33(8):1069-77.
Kreydin EI, Eisner BH. Risk factors for sepsis after percutaneous renal stone surgery. Nature reviews Urology. 2013;10(10):598-605.
Wang X, Li S, Liu T, Guo Y, Yang Z. Laparoscopic pyelolithotomy compared to percutaneous nephrolithotomy as surgical management for large renal pelvic calculi: a meta-analysis. The Journal of urology. 2013;190(3):888-93.
Al-Hunayan A, Khalil M, Hassabo M, Hanafi A, Abdul-Halim H. Management of solitary renal pelvic stone: laparoscopic retroperitoneal pyelolithotomy versus percutaneous nephrolithotomy. Journal of endourology. 2011;25(6):975-8.
Li S, Liu TZ, Wang XH, Zeng XT, Zeng G, Yang ZH, et al. Randomized controlled trial comparing retroperitoneal laparoscopic pyelolithotomy versus percutaneous nephrolithotomy for the treatment of large renal pelvic calculi: a pilot study. Journal of endourology. 2014;28(8):946-50.
Nouralizadeh A, Simforoosh N, Soltani MH, Sarhangnejad R, Ardestanizadeh A, Shabaninia S, et al. Laparoscopic transperitoneal pyelolithotomy for management of staghorn renal calculi. Journal of laparoendoscopic & advanced surgical techniques Part A. 2012;22(1):61-5.
Radfar MH, Kashi AH. Laparoscopic Pyelolithotomy for A Staghorn Stone in A Patient with History of Cystectomy and Ileal Conduit. Urology journal. 2020;17(5):522-4.
Xiao Y, Li Q, Huang C, Wang P, Zhang J, Fu W. Perioperative and long-term results of retroperitoneal laparoscopic pyelolithotomy versus percutaneous nephrolithotomy for staghorn calculi: a single-center randomized controlled trial. World journal of urology. 2019;37(7):1441-7.
D'Agostino D, Corsi P, Giampaoli M, Mineo Bianchi F, Romagnoli D, Crivellaro S, et al. Mini-invasive robotic assisted pyelolithotomy: Comparison between the transperitoneal and retroperitoneal approach. Archivio italiano di urologia, andrologia : organo ufficiale [di] Societa italiana di ecografia urologica e nefrologica. 2019;91(2).
- Abstract Viewed: 0 times
- Just Accepted/6831 Downloaded: 0 times
Download Statastics
In case of persistent problems in registration, primary uploading of a submission or uploading of a revision, please send us the submission files on the journal email at:
urologyjournal@sbmu.ac.ir
and please attach the screenshot of the error or problem you encountered in uploading.