Comparison of Urethral Dilation with Amplatz Dilators and Internal Urethrotomy Techniques for the Treatment of Urethral Strictures
Vol. 17 No. 1 (2020),
26 January 2020
Purpose: The most common option for the management of urethral stricture (US) is direct visual internal urethrotomy (DVIU), because it is an easy and minimally invasive technique but the low success and high recurrence rates of this technique make urologists research for different types of therapeutic alternatives in stricture treatment. In this study we aimed to compare the internal urethrotomy with amplatz dilation for the treatment of male US.
Materials and Methods : A total of sixty patients, who have been operated due to urethral stricture were enrolled into this study. Group 1 was treated with amplatz renal dilators and the group 2 was treated with cold knife urethrotomy. All patients were evaluated for Qmax preoperatively and at the first, 3rd, 9th and 12th months postoperatively.
Results: In the 3 month uroflowmetry results, mean Q max values were 15.6±2 ml/sec in amplatz group and 15.5±1.6 ml/sec in DVIU group. There was no statisticaly difference between the two groups. However the Q max values in the postoperative 9 and 12 months were significantly decreased in the DVIU group. In the DVIU group 9 recurrences (36%) appeared and 2 of these reccurrences were in the first 3 months, whereas in the amplatz group no recurrences appeared in the first 3 months. The urethral stricture recurrence rate up to the 12 month follow up was statistically significant for group 1 when it is compared with group 2.
Conclusions: In our experience, amplatz dilation is a good option as the initial treatment for urethral stricture.
How to Cite
Mundy AR, Andrich DE: Urethral strictures. BJU Int. 2011;107:6–26.
Hızlı F, Berkmen F, Güneş MN, Yürür H. Outcomes of internal urethrotomy after transurethral resection related urethral strictures and literature review. Türk Üroloji Dergisi. 2005;31:417-22.
Van Leeuwen MA, Brandenburg JJ, Kok ET, et al. Management of adult anterior urethral stricture disease: nationwide survey among urologists in the Netherlands. Eur Urol. 2011, 60(1):159-166.
Sachse H. Zur Behandlung der Harnröhren- striktur: die transurethrale Schlitzung unter Sicht mit scharfem Schnitt. Fortschr Med. 1974;92:12–15.
de Kock ML, Allen FJ. Guidelines for the treatment of urethral strictures. S Afr J Surg. 1989;27:182-4.
Chilton CP, Shah PJ, Fowler CG, Tiptaft RC, Blandy JP. The impact of optical urethrotomy on the management of urethral strictures. Br J Urol. 1983;55:705-10.
Santucci RA, Eisenberg L. Urethrotomy has a much lower success rate than previously reported. J Urol. 2010; 183:1859–1862
Cecen K, Karadag MA, Demir A, Kocaaslan R. PlasmaKineticTM versus Cold Knife Internal Urethrotomy in Terms of Recurrence Rates: A Prospective Randomized Study. Urol Int. 2014; DOI: 10.159/000363249.
Akkoc A, Aydin C, Kartalmıs M, et al. Use and outcomes of amplatz renal dilator for treatment of urethral strictures. Int Braz J urol. 2016; 42: 356-64 .
Koca O, Sertkaya Z, Gunes M, et al. Internal urethrotomy ver- sus plasmakinetic energy for surgical treatment of urethral stricture (Article in Turkish). Turkish J Urol. 2011; 37:30-33.
Vicente J, Salvador J, Caffaratti J. Endoscopic urethrotomy versus urethrotomy plus Nd-YAG laser in the treatment of urethral stricture. Eur Urol. 1990;18:166-8.
Stormont TJ, Suman VJ, Oesterling JE. Newly diagnosed bulbar urethral strictures: etiology and outcome of various treatments. J Urol. 1993;150:1725-8.
Gelman J, Liss MA, Cinman NM. Direct vision balloon dilation for the management of urethral strictures. J Endourol. 2011;25:1249-51.
YU S, Wu H, Wang W, et al. High-pressure balloon dilation for male anterior urethral stricture: single-center experience. J Zhejiang Univ-Sci B (Biomed & Biotechnol). 2016 17(9):722-727
Chambers RM, Baitera B. The anatomy of the urethral stricture. Br J Urol. 1977; 49: 545-51.
Isen K, Nalcacioglu V. Direct vision internal urethrotomy by using endoscopic scissors. Int Urol Nephrol. 2015 Jun;47(6):905-8.
Kumar S, Garg N, Singh SK, Mandal AK. Efficacy of Optical Internal Urethrotomy and Intralesional Injection of Vatsala-Santosh PGI Tri-Inject (Triamcinolone, Mitomycin C, and Hyaluronidase) in the Treatment of Anterior Urethral Stricture. Adv Urol. 2014;
Mazdak H, Meshki I, Ghassami F. Effect of mitomycin C on anterior urethral stricture recurrence after internal urethrotomy. Eur Urol. 2007; 51:1089-92.
Yıldırım ME, Kaynar M, Ozyuvali E, et al. The effectiveness of local steroid injection after internal urethrotomy to avoid recurrence. Arch Ital Urol Androl. 2015;87(4):295–8.
Sinanoglu O, Kurtulus FO, Akgün FS. Long Term Effect of Colchicine Treatment in Preventing Urethra Stricture Recurrence After Internal Urethrotomy. Urol J. 2018 Jul 10;15(4):204-208.
Tian Y, Wazir Y, Wang J, Li H. Prevention of stricture recurrence following urethral internal urethrotomy: routine repeated dilations or active surveillance? Urol J. 2016 Aug 25;13(4):2794-6.
Steenkamp JW, Heyns CF, de Kock ML. Internal urethrotomy versus dilation as treatment for male urethral strictures: a prospective, randomized comparison. J Urol. 1997 ;157(1):98-101.
Atak M, Tokgoz H, Akduman B, et al. Low-power holmium:YAG laser urethrotomy for urethral stricture disease: comparison of out- comes with the cold-knife technique. Kaohsiung J Med. 2011; 27:503-507.
Greenwell TJ, Castle C, Andrich DE et al: Repeat urethrotomy and dilation for the treatment of urethral stricture are neither clinically effective not cost-effective. J Urol. 2004; 172: 275.
Naude AM and Heyns CF. What is the place of internal urethrotomy in the treatment of urethral stricture disease? Nat Clin Pract Urol. 2005; 2: 538.
Heyns CF, Steenkamp JW, De Kock ML et al: Treatment of male urethral strictures: is repeated dilation or internal urethrotomy useful? J Urol. 1998; 160: 356.
Morey A: Urethral stricture is now an open surgical disease. J Urol 2009; 181: 953.
- Abstract Viewed: 204 times
- pdf/4662 Downloaded: 108 times