What should accountable care organizations learn from the failure of health maintenance organizations? A theory based systematic review of the literature
Social Determinants of Health,
Vol. 3 No. 4 (2017),
23 April 2018
,
Page 222-247
https://doi.org/10.22037/sdh.v3i4.20919
Abstract
Background: Health Maintenance Organization (HMO), were once viewed as the most cost-effective model for achieving such efficient high-quality health care. A decade after the decline of HMOs a similar idea evolves and continues to proliferate under the rubric of Accountable Care Organizations (ACOs).
Methods: We performed a systematic review according to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses to identify the reasons for the decline of HMOs, with the ultimate goal of extrapolating findings from HMOs experiences onto ACOs. We searched PubMed, Web of Science, and EMBASE to select original research and reports related to the decline of HMOs in the U.S. Using organizational evolving theory the contents of selected studies were analyzed and categorized according to common characteristics.
Results: Although the decline of HMOs varies somewhat from case to case, it follows a fairly consistent pattern with similar causes. These factors were related to wrong ethos, mismanagement, failing to control costs, resistance from provider groups, increased competition, and inadequate IT infrastructure leading to patient dissatisfaction. Patient dissatisfaction in turn led to a managed care backlash, which stimulated the enactment of new restrictive legislation. Restrictive legislation not only negatively impacted the continued growth of HMOs but also accelerated the speed of their decline.
Conclusion: ACOs should set realistic goals, align the incentives for physicians and hospitals via shared savings, use non-physician providers such as nurse practitioners, invest on health information technology, practice patient centered approach, make provider and patients accountable, use efficient management methods and improve care coordination.
- Health Maintenance Organization
- Accountable Care Organization
- Managed Care Program
- Health Care Reform
- Organization Theory
- Systematic Review
How to Cite
References
Marmor T, Oberlander J. From HMOs to ACOs: the quest for the Holy Grail in U.S. health policy. J Gen Intern Med. 2012 Sep;27(9):1215–8.
Saward EW, Greenlick MW. Health Policy and the HMO. In: McKinlay John B., editor. Health Maintenance Organizations: A Milbank Reader. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press; 1981. pp. 1–30. In.
Jonas S, Goldsteen RL, Goldsteen K. An introduction to the US health care system. Springer Publishing Company; 2007.
Coombs J. The rise and fall of HMOs: An American health care revolution. Univ of Wisconsin Press; 2005.
Markovich M. The rise of HMOs. DTIC Document; 2003.
Kongstvedt PR. Essentials of managed health care. Jones & Bartlett Publishers; 2012.
2015 Employer Health Benefits Survey - Section Five: Market Shares of Health Plans [Internet]. [cited 2016 Aug 7]. Available from: http://kff.org/report-section/ehbs-2015-section-five-market-shares-of-health-plans/
Fisher ES, McClellan MB, Safran DG. Building the path to accountable care. N Engl J Med. 2011;365(26):2445–7.
Fisher ES, Staiger DO, Bynum JPW, Gottlieb DJ. Creating Accountable Care Organizations: The Extended Hospital Medical Staff. Health Aff (Millwood) [Internet]. 2007 Jan 1 [cited 2017 Jan 26];26(1):w44–57. Available from: http://content.healthaffairs.org/content/26/1/w44
Frakt AB, Mayes R. Beyond Capitation: How New Payment Experiments Seek To Find The ‘Sweet Spot’ In Amount Of Risk Providers And Payers Bear. Health Aff (Millwood) [Internet]. 2012 Sep 1 [cited 2017 Feb 5];31(9):1951–8. Available from: http://content.healthaffairs.org/content/31/9/1951
Burns LR, Pauly MV. Accountable Care Organizations May Have Difficulty Avoiding The Failures Of Integrated Delivery Networks Of The 1990s. Health Aff (Millwood) [Internet]. 2012 Nov 1 [cited 2016 Aug 7];31(11):2407–16. Available from: http://content.healthaffairs.org/content/31/11/2407
Casalino LP. Accountable care organizations—the risk of failure and the risks of success. Mass Medical Soc; 2014.
Crosson FJ. The Accountable Care Organization: Whatever Its Growing Pains, The Concept Is Too Vitally Important To Fail. Health Aff (Millwood) [Internet]. 2011 Jul 1 [cited 2016 Aug 7];30(7):1250–5. Available from: http://content.healthaffairs.org/content/30/7/1250
Friedman L, Goes J. Why integrated health networks have failed. Front Health Serv Manage. 2001;17(4):3–28.
Aldrich HE, Wiedenmayer G. From traits to rates: An ecological perspective on organizational foundings. Adv Entrep Firm Emergence Growth. 1993;1(3):145–96.
Clegg SR, Hardy C, Nord WR. Handbook of organization studies. SAGE Publications Ltd; 1996.
Hannan MT, Freeman J. The population ecology of organizations. Am J Sociol. 1977;82(5):929–64.
McKelvey B. Organizational systematics--taxonomy, evolution, classification. Univ of California Press; 1982.
Meyer AD. Adapting to environmental jolts. 1982;
Brunsson N. The irrational organization. John Wiley & Sons; 1985.
March JG. Footnotes to organizational change. Adm Sci Q. 1981;563–77.
Miner JB, Crane DP, Vandenberg RJ. Congruence and fit in professional role motivation theory. Organ Sci. 1994;5(1):86–97.
Levitt B, March JG. Organizational learning. Annu Rev Sociol. 1988;14(1):319–38.
Moher D, Liberati A, Tetzlaff J, Altman DG. Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. Ann Intern Med. 2009;151(4):264–9.
Study Quality Assessment Tools - NHLBI, NIH [Internet]. [cited 2017 Nov 7]. Available from: https://www.nhlbi.nih.gov/health-pro/guidelines/in-develop/cardiovascular-risk-reduction/tools
Cummings GG, MacGregor T, Davey M, Lee H, Wong CA, Lo E, et al. Leadership styles and outcome patterns for the nursing workforce and work environment: a systematic review. Int J Nurs Stud. 2010;47(3):363–85.
Singh JV, Lumsden CJ. Theory and research in organizational ecology. Annu Rev Sociol. 1990;16(1):161–95.
Nirschl RP. The rise and fall of HMOs. Orthopedics. 1997 Nov;20(11):1009–10.
Blendon RJ, Hyams TS, Benson JM. Bridging the gap between expert and public views on health care reform. JAMA. 1993 May 19;269(19):2573–8.
MacStravic S. “Managing” demand: the wrong paradigm. Manag Care Q. 1997;5(4):8–17.
Daft RL. Organization theory and design. Cengage learning; 2015.
Clement DG. HMO survival: determination of optimal size. Health Serv Manage Res. 1995;8(1):10–22.
Tisdale T, Liberman A. Managed care--present day challenges and a working model for future consideration. Health Care Manag. 2002 Dec;21(2):46–59.
Gitterman DP, Weiner BJ, Domino ME, McKethan AN, Enthoven AC. The Rise and Fall of a Kaiser Permanente Expansion Region. Milbank Q [Internet]. 2003 Dec [cited 2015 Nov 2];81(4):567–601. Available from: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2690244/
Strumpf GB, Garramone MA. Why some HMOs develop slowly. Public Health Rep [Internet]. 1976 Dec [cited 2017 Nov 12];91(6):496. Available from: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1440581/
Coyne JS, Hansen DJ. HMO financial solvency: should hospitals be concerned? Health Syst Rev. 1992 Oct;25(5):38, 40–3, 49.
Goldman DP, McGlynn EA. US Health Care—Facts about cost, access, and quality. The RAND Corporation 2005. 2011.
Cutler DM, McClellan M. Is Technological Change In Medicine Worth It? Health Aff (Millwood) [Internet]. 2001 Sep 1 [cited 2015 Nov 10];20(5):11–29. Available from: http://content.healthaffairs.org/content/20/5/11
Leutz W, Malone J, Kistner M, O’Bar T, Ripley JM, Sandhaus M. Financial performance in the social health maintenance organization, 1985-88. Health Care Financ Rev. 1990;12(1):9–18.
Long SH, Settle RF, Wrightson CW. Employee premiums, availability of alternative plans, and HMO disenrollment. Med Care. 1988 Oct;26(10):927–38.
Enthoven AC. Why managed care has failed to contain health costs. Health Aff Proj Hope. 1993;12(3):27–43.
Hurley RE, Strunk BC, White JS. The puzzling popularity of the PPO. Health Aff Proj Hope. 2004 Apr;23(2):56–68.
Freeman J, Hannan MT. Setting the record straight on organizational ecology: Rebuttal to Young. University of Chicago Press; 1989.
Singh JV. Density dependence theory-Current issues, future promise. University of Chicago Press; 1993.
Burns LR, Thorpe DP. Why provider-sponsored health plans don’t work. Healthc Financ Manag J Healthc Financ Manag Assoc. 2001;Suppl:12–6.
Reece RL. Bumps on the managed care road: the search for an alternative model to reduce collisions between HMOs, physicians, and patients. Manag Care Q. 2000;8(3):27–33.
Greene SB. The rise and decline of managed care. What comes next? N C Med J. 2003 Feb;64(1):21–9.
Mechanic D. The rise and fall of managed care. J Health Soc Behav. 2004;76–86.
Relman A. The decline and fall of managed care. Hosp Health Netw AHA. 1998 Jul 5;72(13):70, 72.
Trauner JB. Reassessing the plight of physician organizations in California: the uncertain future for IPAs. J Ambulatory Care Manage. 2000 Jul;23(3):28–38.
Serrato C, Brown RS, Bergeron J. Why do so few HMOs offer Medicare risk plans in rural areas? Health Care Financ Rev. 1995;17(1):85–97.
Harrison DH, Kimberly JR. HMOs don’t have to fail. Harv Bus Rev. 1982 Aug;60(4):115–24.
Cohen WM, Levinthal DA. Absorptive capacity: A new perspective on learning and innovation. Adm Sci Q. 1990;128–52.
Steiner JF, Price DW, Chandramouli V, Goodspeed JR. Managed care for uninsured adults: the rise and fall of a university-based program. Am J Manag Care. 2002 Jul;8(7):653–61.
Morrisey MA, Ohsfeldt RL. Do “any willing provider” and “freedom of choice” laws affect HMO market share? Inq J Med Care Organ Provis Financ. 2003;40(4):362–74.
Mechanic D, Weiss N, Cleary PD. The growth of HMOs: issues of enrollment and disenrollment. Med Care. 1983 Mar;21(3):338–47.
Rutledge RW, Nascimento P. Satisfaction with HMOs. Accessibility issues top the list for patients in commercial groups. J Health Care Mark. 1996;16(1):22–7.
Dwore RB, Murray BP, Parsons RP, Gustafson G. An opportunity for HMOs to use marketing to increase enrollee satisfaction. Manag Care Langhorne Pa. 2001 Jan;10(1):38–9, 43–5, 49-52 passim.
Gamble JE, Icenogle ML, Bryan NB, Rickert DA. The effects of open access on member satisfaction and intentions to remain in an HMO. Health Care Manage Rev. 2000;25(4):34–47.
Nauert RC. Strategic health system development and managed care delivery. J Health Care Finance. 2002;29(2):5–17.
Meyer JW, Rowan B. Institutionalized organizations: Formal structure as myth and ceremony. Am J Sociol. 1977;83(2):340–63.
Udow M. Has managed care failed? The answer is: yes and no. J Med Pract Manag MPM. 2002 Aug;18(1):19–23.
Blendon RJ, Brodie M, Benson JM, Altman DE, Levitt L, Hoff T, et al. Understanding the managed care backlash. Health Aff (Millwood) [Internet]. 1998 Jul 1 [cited 2015 Nov 7];17(4):80–94. Available from: http://content.healthaffairs.org/content/17/4/80
Christianson JB, Trude S. Managing Costs, Managing Benefits: Employer Decisions in Local Health Care Markets. Health Serv Res [Internet]. 2003 Feb [cited 2017 Feb 23];38(1 Pt 2):357. Available from: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1360890/
Hurley RE, Draper DA. Health plan responses to managed care regulation. Manag Care Q. 2002;10(4):30–42.
Christianson JB, Wholey DR, Sanchez SM. State responses to HMO failures. Health Aff Proj Hope. 1991;10(4):78–92.
Lampton L. Mississippi is blessed by HMO failure. J Miss State Med Assoc. 2000 Jan;41(1):466.
Glavin MP, Tompkins CP, Wallack SS, Altman SH. An examination of factors in the withdrawal of managed care plans from the Medicare+ Choice program. Inq J Health Care Organ Provis Financ. 2002;39(4):341–54.
Feldman R, Wholey D, Christianson J. A descriptive economic analysis of HMO mergers and failures, 1985-1992. Med Care Res Rev MCRR. 1995 Jun;52(2):279–304.
Bushick JB. Creating an integrated health care system as a basis for managed care excellence: a health plan’s perspective. Manag Care Q. 1995;3(1):1–10.
Balla SJ. Markets, governments, and HMO development in the 1990s. J Health Polit Policy Law. 1999 Apr;24(2):215–38.
Christianson JB, Sanchez SM, Wholey DR, Shadle M. The HMO industry: evolution in population demographics and market structures. Med Care Rev. 1991;48(1):3–46.
McConnell KJ, Renfro S, Chan BKS, Meath THA, Mendelson A, Cohen D, et al. Early Performance in Medicaid Accountable Care Organizations: A Comparison of Oregon and Colorado. JAMA Intern Med [Internet]. 2017 Apr 1 [cited 2017 Nov 12];177(4):538–45. Available from: https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamainternalmedicine/fullarticle/2601417
McWilliams JM, Gilstrap LG, Stevenson DG, Chernew ME, Huskamp HA, Grabowski DC. Changes in postacute care in the Medicare Shared Savings Program. JAMA Intern Med. 2017;177(4):518–26.
Hsu J, Price M, Vogeli C, Brand R, Chernew ME, Chaguturu SK, et al. Bending The Spending Curve By Altering Care Delivery Patterns: The Role Of Care Management Within A Pioneer ACO. Health Aff (Millwood) [Internet]. 2017 Sep 5 [cited 2017 Nov 12]; Available from: http://www.healthaffairs.org/doi/10.1377/hlthaff.2016.0922
Blackstone EA, Fuhr JP. The Economics of Medicare Accountable Care Organizations. Am Health Drug Benefits [Internet]. 2016 Feb [cited 2017 Feb 4];9(1):11–9. Available from: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4822974/
aco_whitepaper.pdf [Internet]. [cited 2017 Feb 4]. Available from: http://www.athenahealth.com/~/media/athenaweb/files/whitepapers/aco_whitepaper.pdf
Montoya ID, Perez BA. Access as a managed care marketing outcomes measure. Health Mark Q. 2000;17(3):1–12.
Cutler DM, Morton FS. Hospitals, Market Share, and Consolidation. JAMA [Internet]. 2013 Nov 13 [cited 2017 Nov 12];310(18):1964–70. Available from: https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/1769891
Morrisey MA, Ashby CS. An empirical analysis of HMO market share. Inq J Med Care Organ Provis Financ. 1982;19(2):136–49.
Weil TP. Accountable care organizations: HMOs by another name? J Fam Pract. 2012 Jan;61(1):10.
Muhlestein D, McClellan M. Accountable care organizations in 2016: private and public-sector growth and dispersion. Health Aff Blog. 2016;
Saving the Shared Savings Program (ACOs): Specific Suggestions for Success–Part One [Internet]. Health Affairs. [cited 2017 Feb 5]. Available from: http://healthaffairs.org/blog/2011/05/17/saving-the-shared-savings-program-acos-specific-suggestions-for-success-part-one/
Terry K. Health IT: the glue for accountable care organizations. Four big systems show how they’re using EHRs, connectivity, and data warehouses to drive ACOs. Healthc Inform Bus Mag Inf Commun Syst. 2011 May;28(5):16, 18, 20 passim.
Simonet D. Patient satisfaction under managed care. Int J Health Care Qual Assur Inc Leadersh Health Serv. 2005;18(6–7):424–40.
Kennedy GD, Tevis SE, Kent KC. Is There a Relationship Between Patient Satisfaction and Favorable Outcomes? Ann Surg [Internet]. 2014 Oct [cited 2017 Feb 5];260(4):592–600. Available from: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4159721/
McCurren JK. Factors for success: capitated primary physicians in Medicare HMOs. Health Care Manage Rev. 1991;16(2):49–53.
Stefanacci RG. Accountable care--but the patient isn’t accountable. Manag Care Langhorne Pa. 2011 Jul;20(7):33–4.
webadmin. What Does Trumpcare Mean for the Future of ACOs? [Internet]. Managed Care Magazine Online. 2016 [cited 2017 Feb 6]. Available from: https://www.managedcaremag.com/editorsdesk/what-does-trumpcare-mean-future-acos
Wolinsky FD. The performance of Health Maintenance Organizations: an analytic review. Milbank Mem Fund Q Health Soc. 1980;58(4):537–87.
Weil TP. Why are ACOs doomed for failure? J Med Pract Manag MPM. 2012 Apr;27(5):263–7.
- Abstract Viewed: 756 times
- PDF Downloaded: 386 times