Moral challenges of research on embryos in pre-implantation genetic diagnosis and IVF

Leila Naseri, Mahmoud Abbasi, Mehrdad Hashemi

Abstract


132

     Purposes of pre-implantation genetic diagnosis (PGD) include screening for single gene mutations for late onset disorders or susceptibility to cancer. The problematic issue is that PGD is to produce a healthy baby, causing the destruction of some embryos that have been transferred by in vitro fertilization (IVF). Some PGD embryos may be discarded because they are excess to the woman or couples’ goal for family creation, and have been diagnosed as being affected by a particular genetic condition that woman/couple wish to avoid. So, the controversial issue is the destruction of embryos as a consequence of fertility treatment that raises questions on whether the moral status of an embryo of 3 days is the same as that of a born, living adult human being.


Keywords


discarding embryos; PGD; IVF; embryos as a person; research

Full Text:

PDF

133

References


Robertson JA. Extending preimplantation genetic diagnosis: the ethical debate: Ethical issues in new uses of preimplantation genetic diagnosis. Human Reproduction. 2003; 18(3): 465-471.

Braude P, Pickering S, Flintier F, Ogilvie CM. Pre-implantation genetic diagnosis. Nature Reviews Genetics. 2002; 3(12): 941-955.

Spallone P. Beyond conception: the new politics of reproduction. 1989.

Solter D, Beyleveld D, Friele MB, Holwka J, Lilli H, Lovell-Badge R, Mandla C, Martin U, Pardo Avellaneda R, Wütscher F. Embryo Research in Pluralistic Europe. Heidelberg, Germany: Springer. 2004.

Savulescu J. The case for creating human-nonhuman cell lines. In Bioethics Forum. 2007.

Clark AT, Bodnar MS, Fox M, Rodriquez RT, Abeyta MJ, Firpo MT, Pera RAR. Spontaneous differentiation of germ cells from human embryonic stem cells in vitro. Human molecular genetics. 2004; 13(7): 727-739.[Pub Med]

Chen HF, Kuo HC, Chien CL, Shun CT, Yao YL, IP PL, Ho HN. Derivation, characterization and differentiation of human embryonic stem cells: comparing serum-containing versus serum-free media and evidence of germ cell differentiation. Human Reproduction. 2006; 22(2): 567-577.

Testa G, Harris J. Ethics and synthetic gametes. Bioethics. 2005; 19(2): 146-166.[PubMed]

Chung Y, Klimanskaya I, Becker S, Marh J, Lu SJ, Johnson J, Lanza R. Embryonic and

extraembryonic stem cell lines derived from single mouse blastomeres. Nature. 2006; 439(7073): 216-219.[PubMed]

Klimanskaya I, Chung Y, Becker S, Lu SJ, Lanza R. Human embryonic stem cell lines derived from single blastomeres. Nature. 2006; 444(7118): 481-485.[PubMed]

Drusenheimer N, Wulf G, Nolte J, Lee JH, Dev A, Dressel R, Nayernia K. Putative human male germ cells from bone marrow stem cells. Society of Reproduction and Fertility supplement. 2007; 4(5): 63-69. [PubMed]

Takahashi K, Tanabe K, Ohnuki M, Narita M, Ichisaka T, Tomoda K, Yamanaka S. Induction of pluripotent stem cells from adult human fibroblasts by defined factors. Cell. 2007; 131(2): 861–872 [PubMed]

Yu J, Vodyanik MA, Smuga-Otto K, Antosiewicz-Bourget J, Frane JL, Tian, S, Slukvin II. Induced pluripotent stem cell lines derived from human somatic cells. science. 2007; 318(5858): 1917-1920. [PubMed]

Nakagawa M, Koyanagi M, Tanabe K, Takahashi K, Ichisaka T, Aoi T, Yamanaka S. Generation of induced pluripotent stem cells without Myc from mouse and human fibroblasts. Nature biotechnology. 2008; 26(1): 101-106. [PubMed]

Park IH, Zhao R, West JA, Yabuuchi A, Huo H, Ince TA, Daley GQ. Reprogramming of human somatic cells to pluripotency with defined factors. Nature; 2008; 451(7175): 141-146. [PubMed]

Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority. Human Embryo Research in the UK, 2006/2007. London, UK: Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority. 2007.

Tonti-Filippini N. The Catholic church and reproductive technology. Bioethics: An Anthology, H Kuhse, P Singer (Eds). 1999: 93-95.

Liao SM. The embryo rescue case. Theoretical medicine and bioethics. 2006; 27(2): 141-147. [PubMed]

Annas GJ. At Law: A French Homunculus in a Tennessee Court. The Hastings Center Report. 1989; 19(6): 20-22. [PubMed]

Leridon H. Human fertility. University of Chicago Press. 1977.

Boklage CE. Survival probability of human conceptions from fertilization to term. Int J Fertil. 1990; 35(2): 74-75. [PubMed]

Ord T. The scourge: moral implications of natural embryo loss. The American Journal of Bioethics. 2008; 8(7): 12-19. [PubMed].

Murphy TF. The moral significance of spontaneous abortion. Journal of medical ethics. 1985; 11(2): 79-83.[PMC free article] [PubMed].

Fleck LM. Abortion, deformed fetuses, and the omega pill. Philosophical studies. 1979; 36(3): 271-283.[PubMed].

Fleck LM. Mending mother nature: alpha, beta and omega pills. Philosophical Studies. 1984; 46(3): 381-393.

Sandel MJ. The ethical implications of human cloning. Perspectives in biology and medicine.

; 48(2): 241-247.[PubMed].

McMahan J. The ethics of killing: Problems at the margins of life. Oxford University Press on Demand. 2002.

Savulescu J. Should we clone human beings? Cloning as a source of tissue for transplantation. Journal of Medical Ethics. 1999; 25(2): 87-95. [PMC free article] [PubMed]

Airedale NHS. Trust v Bland [1993] 1 All ER 821. London, UK: House of Lords. 1996. [PubMed].

Brusseau R, Myers L. Developing consciousness: fetal anesthesia and analgesia. In Seminars in Anesthesia, Perioperative Medicine and Pain. 2006; 25(4): 189-195.

Derbyshire SW. Controversy: Can fetuses feel pain?. BMJ: British Medical Journal. 2006; 332(7546): 908- 909.‏ [PMC free article] [PubMed]

Anand KJ, Hickey PR. Pain and its effects in the human neonate and fetus. N Engl j Med. 1987; 317(21): 1321-1329.‏[PubMed].

Burgess JA, Tawia SA. When did you first begin to feel it?—locating the beginning of human consciousness. Bioethics. 1996; 10(1): 1-26. [PubMed]

Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists. Fetal Awareness. London, UK: Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists. 1997.

Mellor DJ, Diesch TJ, Gunn AJ, Bennet L. The importance of ‘awareness’ for understanding fetal pain. Brain research reviews. 2005; 49(3): 455-471.‏[PubMed].

Lee SJ, Ralston HJP, Drey EA, Partridge JC, Rosen MA. Fetal pain: a systematic multidisciplinary review of the evidence. Jama. 2005; 294(8): 947-954.‏ [PubMed]

Van de Velde M, Jani J, De Buck F, Deprest J. Fetal pain perception and pain management. In Seminars in Fetal and Neonatal Medicine. 2006; 11(4): 232-236. [PubMed]

Savulescu J. Is current practice around late termination of pregnancy eugenic and discriminatory? Maternal interests and abortion. Journal of Medical Ethics. 2001; 27(3): 165-171.‏

Singer P. Practical ethics. Cambridge university press.‏ 2011.

Williams B. The human prejudice. In

Philosophy as a Humanistic Discipline, AW Moore (Ed), p 142. Princeton, NJ, USA: Princeton University Press. 2008.

Finnis J. Unjust laws in a democratic society: Some philosophical and theological reflections. Notre Dame L. Rev., 1995; 71(2): 594-595.‏

Savulescu J. Abortion, embryo destruction and the future of value argument.‏2002.[PMC free article] [PubMed]

Savulescu J. Gene therapy, transgenesis and chimeras: is the radical genetic alteration of human beings a threat to our humanity?. In Quest of Ethical Wisdom: How the Practical Ethics of East and West Contribute to Wisdom. Oxford: Oxford Uehiro Centre for Practical Ethics. 2007:3-20.‏

Savulescu J. The human prejudice and the moral status of enhanced beings: what do we owe the gods?.‏ 2009.

Marquis D. Why abortion is immoral. The Journal of Philosophy. 1989; 86(4): 183-202.‏ [PubMed]

McMahan J. Killing embryos for stem cell research. Metaphilosophy. 2007; 38(2‐3): 170-189.‏

Harris J. The survival lottery. Philosophy. 1975; 50(191): 81-87.‏[PubMed]

Savulescu J. The embryonic stem cell lottery and the cannibalization of human beings. Bioethics. 2002; 16(6): 508-529.‏[PubMed].

Devolder K. Human embryonic stem cell research: Why the discarded‐created‐distinction cannot be based on the potentiality argument. Bioethics. 2005; 19(2): 167-186.‏ [PubMed]

Devolder K. Creating and sacrificing embryos for stem cells. Journal of Medical Ethics. 2005; 31(6); 366-370.‏ [PMC free article] [PubMed].

Verlinsky, Y., Rechitsky, S., Schoolcraft, W., Strom, C., & Kuliev, A. (2001). Preimplantation diagnosis for Fanconi anemia combined with HLA matching. Jama, 285(24), 3130-3133.

Pennings, G., Schots, R., & Liebaers, I. (2002). Ethical considerations on preimplantation genetic diagnosis for HLA typing to match a future child as a donor of haematopoietic stem cells to a sibling. Human Reproduction, 17(3), 534-538.

Devolder, K. (2005). Preimplantation HLA typing: having children to save our loved ones. Journal of Medical Ethics, 31(10), 582-586.

Packman, W. L. (1999). Psychosocial impact of pediatric BMT on siblings. Bone Marrow Transplantation, 24(7), 701.

Pennings, G. (2004, April). Saviour siblings: using preimplantation genetic diagnosis for tissue typing. In International congress series (Vol. 1266, pp. 311-317). Elsevier.

Redmon, R. B. (1986). How children can be respected as' ends' yet still be used as subjects in non-therapeutic research. Journal of medical ethics, 12(2), 77-82.

Dahl, E., Beutel, M., Brosig, B., & Hinsch, K. D. (2003). Preconception sex selection for non‐medical reasons: a representative survey from Germany. Human Reproduction, 18(10), 2231-2234.

Zubair, F., Dahl, E. S. S. S., Sher Shah, S., Ahmed, M., &Brosig, B. (2006). Gender preferences and demand for preconception sex selection: a survey among pregnant women in Pakistan. Human reproduction, 22(2), 605-609.

Robertson, J. A. (2002). Sex selection for gender variety by preimplantation genetic diagnosis. Fertility and sterility, 78(3), 463.

McDougall, R. (2005). Acting parentally: an argument against sex selection. Journal of Medical Ethics, 31(10), 601-605.

Harris, J. (2005). Sex selection and regulated hatred. Journal of Medical Ethics, 31(5), 291-294.

Harris, J. (2005). Sex selection and regulated hatred. Journal of Medical Ethics, 31(5), 291-294.

Berkowitz, J. M., & Snyder, J. W. (1998). Racism and sexism in medically assisted conception. Bioethics, 12(1), 25-44.

Ziberberg J (2007) sex selection and restricting abortion and sex determination. Bioethics, 21(9) . p.517-519

Rogers, W., Ballantyne, A., & Draper, H. (2007). IS SEX‐SELECTIVE ABORTION MORALLY JUSTIFIED AND SHOULD IT BE PROHIBITED?. Bioethics, 21(9), 520-524.

Moayeri M, Saeidi H, Modarresi MH, Hashemi M. The Effect of Preimplantation Genetic Screening on Implantation Rate in Women over 35 Years of Age. Cell Journal. 2016; 18(1):13-20

Farahmand K, KalantariH, Fakhri M, Shahzadeh Fazeli A, Zari Moradi, Almadani N, Hashemi M, Gourabi H, Mohseni Meybodi A. Evaluation of 1100 couples with recurrent pregnancy loss using conventional cytogenetic, PGD, and PGS: hype or hope. Gynecological Endocrinology, 2016;12(6):483-487

Farahmand K, Totonchi M, Hashemi M,

Reyhani Sabet F, Kalantari H, Gourabi H, Mohseni Meybodi A. Thrombophilic genes alterations as risk factor for recurrent pregnancy loss: J Matern Fetal Neonatal Med, 2016;29(8):1269-1273




DOI: https://doi.org/10.22037/jps.v9i2.19136

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


"Journal of Paramdedical Sciences", is a publication of "School of Paramedical Sciences, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences" and "Iranian Society of Medical Proteomics".

"Journal of Paramdedical Sciences" is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.

 

EISSN: 2008-4978

PISSN: 2008-496X