Evaluation of Data Recording at Teaching Hospitals

  • Hasan Karbasi Faculty Member of Birjand University of Medicine
  • M Ziai
  • M Hosaini


Background and purpose: Medical records of patients have an undeniable role on education, research and evaluation of health care delivery, and also could be used as reliable documents of past in cases

of patients’ legal complains. This study was done to evaluate medical data recording at teaching hospital of Birjand University of Medical Sciences in 2004.

Methods: In this descriptive-analytic study, 527 patients’ records of patients who had been discharged from general wards of the hospitals after 24 hours of hospitalization were randomly selected. 18 standard titles of records include in each patient’s record were evaluated using checklists. Data were analyzed using frequency distribution tables, independent t-test and Chi-square test.

Results: Items on records’ titles were completed in a range of 0-100%. Titles of neonates and nursing care with 96% completeness were the most completed ones~ Titles of recovery, pre-delivery care, medical history, summary, and progress notes with 50% to 74% completeness were categorized as moderately completed titles; and titles of vital signs, pre-operation care and operation report were weak. Records of the infectious diseases ward were the most completed records (68%) and the least completed were from ophthmology ward (35.8%). There were significant differences between the hospitals and between different wards.

Conclusion: Results of this study show the need for further education on record writing, taking medical history, and order writing and more importantly the need for a system of continuous monitoring

of the records.



Tabibi SJ, Rabiee R, SAdooghi F. Evaluation of performance of medical record unit of specially teaching hospital of Iran medical universities. Science-research quartery of medical university of Kashan, Feyz.2004;8


Somi MH, Piri Z Delgoshaei B, Mahmoodi Z. Are the medical records of high quality in teaching hospitals? Journal of medical education.2004;5(1).

Tavakoli N, Tabasi J. Medical records at University of Esfehan. [Ms thesis]. Tehran: Iran Medical University;1997.

Moradi GH, Fesharaki M. study of rate of use of medical records in clinical research at Medical University of Khorasan. [Ms thesis].

Tehran: Iran Medical University;1995.

Sadrodin F. Medical records in view of forensic medicine. Journal of forensic Medicine 1998.4(13):84-103.

Hatam N, Heshmati Y, Ayatollahi SA. Role of medical records to increase efficiency and income of hospitals. Proceedings of the 4th national Congress of Medical Records in Iran. 2004 Dec 22-25; Tehran,Iran. Tehran: Ministry of Health Publications; 2005

Ariai M, Fesharaki M. Study of contents of medical records at general hospitals related to Medical University of Kerman. [Ms Thesis].

Tehran: Iran Medical University, faculty of management and information 1999.

Ahmadzadeh F, Raisie P. Study of completeness level of medical study at general hospitals of Medical University of Shiraz. [Ms Thesis]. Tehran: Iran Medical University, faculty of management and information; 1999.

Asadi F, Sadeghiani E. Quality of medical records teaching hospitals of Iran Medical University and presenting a suitable pattern. [Ms Thesis]. Tehran: Iran Medical University, faculty of management and information;1998.

Tavakoli N. Role of managers of health care data in decreasing medical faults and increasing quality of care. 2004 Dec 22-25; Tehran,Iran.

Tehran: Ministry of Health Publications; 2005

Original (Research) Articles