A Survey of University of Medical Sciences’ Administrators and GPs on the Current and Ideal Role of General Practitioners in Iran

Bijan Geraili, F Azizi, Sh Yazdani, A Amini, A Mortazavi, M Hosseinzadeh

Abstract


277

Background and purpose: roles and tasks of intended graduates direct medical eductionist for developing the right curriculum. In Iran there has been no systematic study on defining GPs roles. This study is an attempt to systematically clarify the roles of GPs in Iran.
Methods: In this questionnaire – based survey executive directors of Universities of medicine of Iran and general practitioners participated. The subjects were selected through stratified sampling procedure. A semi-structured questionnaire was developed which covered the goals and functions of health system as mentioned in World Health Report 2000. For content validity a panel of experts including health care professionals, biostatisticians, and psychometrist evaluated the questionnaire. For the reliability of the questionnaire a pilot study was carried out. Chronbach’s coeficient were calculated as 0.89 .The final revision of the questionnaire included 15 roles in current and ideal states. The respondent should score each role in both states in a range of 0-100.
Results: Of 94 subjects who received the questionnaire, 71 (80%) completed and returned it. Of all subjects 42.2% were female and 57.8% were male. Of all subjects 25% were faculty members. The subjects believe that in the current state “health care provision” (85.4±18.6) “health center administration” (57.8±24.8), and “leading clinical services and coordinating patients care” (47.6±26.8) are more evident while “fund holding” had the lowest rank(5.0±10.0). They believed that in an ideal national health system physicians should play most of these roles in various extents.
Conclusion: The participants believed that GPs should play other roles beyond the clinical care provision to enable health system respond to community needs and expectations. The graduate medical degree should be reformed if the gradates are going to play these new roles.
Key words: Role Definition, Curr iculum Development, GP, Primary Health care

Keywords


Role Definition, Curr iculum Development, GP, Primary Health care

Full Text:

PDF

164

References


: Kern , D.E.et al. Curriculum Development for Medical Education : A six step approach (Balti-more, Johns Hopkins university press)1998.

:William .RP,Deborah. G . The domain of family practice: Scope, Role, and function. Family medi¬cine 2001; 33 (4) : 273-277.

: Schwarz.MR , wojtczak.A. Global minimum essential requirements: A road towards compe¬tence-oriented medical education, Medical teacher ,2002; 24(2:125-129

: Simpson.JG , Furnance.J, Crosby.J et al. The Scottish doctor-learning outcomes for the medi¬cal undergraduate in scotland: A foundation for competent and reflective practitioners, Medical teacher 2002; 24(2): 136-143

: Boelen.C . World Health Organization , Geneva , Switzerland. The five-star doctor: An asset to health care reform?

:The World Health Report 2000-Health systems:improving performance. Geneva,World Health Organization,2000.

Yazdani Sh, Hatami S. General practitioners in Iran, tasks and educational needs, metods and application of results. Tehran: Education Devel¬opment Center of Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences;2004.

: Olesen.F, Dickinson.J, Hjortdah.P . Gen¬eral practice—time for a new definition. BMJ, 2000;320:354-357.

:Anderson . B , Cohen . JJ et al . learning ob¬jectives for medical student education guidelines for medical schools . New york : Association of American medical colleges , J Med Educ .1998.

: Frank .JR .(Ed).The Can MEDS 2005. physi¬cian competency framework Better standards.Bet¬ter physicians.Better careOttawa:The Royal Col¬lege of physicians and surgeons of Canada . 2005

:Frank.JR, Jabbour.M , Tugwell.p et al . skills for the new millennium.Report of the societal needs working group , Can MEDS 2000 project .Ann R Coll physicians surg Can 1996;29: 206-216.

:Tumulty.PA.TheEffective clinician. Philadelphia,pa :W.B.Saunders ;1973:1.

: Herbert.CP.The fifth principle family physi¬cians as advocates . Canadian family physician . 2001 ; 47 : 2441 – 2443.

:Newfeld.VR,Maudsley.RF. et al.Educating fu¬ture physicians for Ontario . Academic medicine ,1998;73(11) : 1133-1148.

:Maudsley.RF,Wilson.DR , Newfeld .VR ,et al .Educating future physicians for Ontario: phase II. Academic medicine . 2000 ; 75(2) : 113- 126 .

:Goh.LG,Cgeong.PY.The training of futuredoc¬tors.Singapore Med J. 1998; 39(12) :524-526 .

:Sangster.LM , Mc Guire.DP . Perceived role of primary care physicians in Nova scotia’s reformed health care system . Canadian family physician . 1999 ; 45 : 97-101

: Canadian medical Association . strengthening the foundation . The role of the physician in pri-mary health care in Canada . Ottawa , ont : Cana¬dian medical Association ; 1994.

: Rademakers.JJDJM , Rooy.ND ,Ten cate.TG . Senior medical students appraisal of CanMeds competencies.Medical Education.2007:41:990-994.

: Ringsted.C , Hansen.TL , Davis.D et al . Are some of the challenging aspects of the CanMEDS roles valid outside Canada? Medical Education . 2006;40:807-815.

: Bodenheimer.T .Hight and rising health care costs . part 2: Technologic innovation .Ann intern Med 2005;142(11):932-937.

: Enthoven .A ,Kronick .R. A consumer – Choice health plan for the 1990 . universal health insur¬ance in a system designed to promote quality and economy . N Engl J Med .1989;320(1):29-37.

: Kravitz .R.L . Beyond gatekeeping . Enlisting patients as agents for quality and cost containment . J Gen Intern Med. 2008 ;23(10):1722-1723.

:Haggerty.JL,Reid.RJ,Freeman.GK et al. Continuity of care:A multidisciplinary review , BMJ.2003; 327 : 1219 – 1221 .

: Freeman .G .K , Olesen . F . et al. Continuity of care : An essential of modern general practice ? Fam Pract . 2003 ; 20 : 623 – 627

: Aagaard.E.M , Hauer.K.E.A. Cross – Sec¬tional descriptive study of mentoring relationships formed by medical students . J Gen intern Med. 2003 ; 18: 298-302.

: Tosteson.D.C. Learning in medicine . N Engl J Med . 1979;301: 690- 694 .

: Romberg.E. Mentoring the individual student : Qualities that distinguish between effective and ineffective advisors . J Dent Educ . 1993; 57: 287-290.

: Mohayosnand.P.P : The need for mentoring in public health . American journal of public health . 1999; 89(8) : 1262- 1263.

: Freeman.R. Report of a forum for mentoring in general practice . Education for General Prac-tice 1994 ;5: 311-312.

: Freeman.R. Mentoring in general practice . Education for General practice . 1995 ; 7: 112- 117.

: Freeman.R. Towards effective mentoring in general practice.British journal of general practice . 1997; 47: 457- 460 .

: Armsrong.E. Doctors as health promoters .Mod¬ule A .1999. London , Health education Authority . 34:Amos.A , Church.M , et al . A health promo¬tion module for undergraduate medical students , Medical Education .1991; 22: 328 -335.

:Weare.K. To what extent dose medical edu¬cation Concern it self with the medical students‘ own health ? Health Education journal . 1998; 57: 240- 253 .

: Naidoo.J ,Drme.J.Health promotion in the medical curriculum : enhancing its potential.Med¬ical Teacher .2000 ; 22(3) : 282-287.

: Parsell.G , Spalding.R , Bligh .L . Shared Learn¬ing : Evaluation of a multiprofessional Course for undergraduate Students . Medical Teacher . 1999; 2(1) : 99 .

: Light.DW, Hughes.D. Introduction : A socio¬logical perspective on rationing power , rhetoric and situated practices . Sociology of health and Ill¬ness. 2001;23(5): 551- 569 .

: Mechanic.D. Dilemmas in rationing health care services : the case for implicit rationing . BMJ .1995;310: 1655-1659.

: Ferris.TG, Chang .YC, Blumental .D et al . Leaving gatekeeping behind – Effects of opening access to Specialists for adults in a health main¬tenance organization .New England journal of medicine .2001;345(18):1312-1317.

: Allen .J et al .The European definition of gen¬eral practice/ family practice .WONCA. Europe .2005 Edition

: GlennerSter .H et al . Implementing GP foundholding : wild card or winning hand ? open university press Buckingham. 1994.

: Gosden.T, Torgenson.D. The effect of fund¬holding on prescribing and referral costs . A review of the evidence . health policy . 1997;40(2):103-114.

: Robinson.R. The impact of NHS reforms 1991-5: A review of research evidence .Journal of public Health Medicine ,1996;18(3): 337-343.

: Smith.R, Wilton.p . General practice found¬holding : progress to date British journal of gen¬eral practice .1998;48:1253-1257.

: Azeem .M , Lawrence.M. Unified budgets for primary care groups . BMJ . 1999;318:772-776.




DOI: https://doi.org/10.22037/jme.v13i1,2.1130

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.