Studying the four temperaments in medical hadiths of Ahl al-Bayt (AS) and comparing the results with temperament medicine
Background and Objective: A major proportion of discussions in temperament medicine have to do with the four types of temperament, namely phlegmatic, melancholic, choleric, and sanguine. Similar titles can be detected in medical hadiths of Ahl al-Bayt (AS). The question is: Are the temperaments proposed in hadiths equivalent to the ones explicated in traditional medicine? The current study sought to answer this question.
Method: Following an explanatory-comparative design, the study utilized content analysis to explain temperaments from the perspective of Ahl al Bayt’s hadiths. The results were then compared with Hippocrates’ ideas in traditional medicine. The research focused on reference books in hadiths and traditional medicine. All ethical issues were observed in this study and the researchers declared no conflict of interests.
Results: The results indicated that, in hadiths, the term “temperament” refers to different mixtures of human body. The four mixtures of human body include rih, marrah, blood, and phlegm. No reference has been made to black bile and yellow bile in hadiths. On the other hand, some experts believe that black bile and yellow bile are subcategories of marrah. According to traditional medicine, the four elements of earth, water, air, and fire correspond to the four temperaments of melancholic, phlegmatic, sanguine, and choleric respectively. Also, another subtle material, known as vapor spirit, originates from the four temperaments.
Conclusion: Based on the obtained results, there are similarities between what has been dubbed “four temperaments and vapor spirit” in traditional medicine and what has been discussed in medical hadiths about the body mixture of humans.
Please cite this article as: Saadati A, Naghizadeh H, Seyed Mosavi SH. Studying the four temperaments in medical hadiths of Ahl al-Bayt (AS) and comparing the results with temperament medicine. J Res Relig Health. 2018; 4(3): 118- 128.
Ghaffari F, Naseri M, Khodadoust M. The Iranian traditional medicine and its reasons to restore and develop. Medincine and Tazkieh Journal.9(3):63-71. (Full Text in Persian)
Naseri M, Rezaea zadeh H, Taheri panah T. The need to develop traditional medicine and complementary views of the World Health Organization. Pazhvak Journal. spring 2007;1(2):2-7. (Full Text in Persian)
Mozaffarpur SA, Taghavi M, Mirzapor M. Investigating the difference between principals of Iranian traditional medicine and modern medicine for providing a model for integrated medicine, Babol Univ of Med Sciences. Islam and Health Journal. 2014;1(1):10-15. (Full Text in Persion)
Nourmohammadi Gh. Writing of medical hadiths. Journal of Pazhouhesh and Houwzah, 5;110-25. (Full Text in Persian)
Naghizadeh H, Rezadad E. The discussion of Imam Reza, properties and methods. Meshkat journal. 2008;94:107-25. (Full Text in persian)
Naghizadeh H, Saeadi H. Thought in validity and usage of criterion of Hadith textual critic in Sunnite viewpoint. Ketabe Ghayyem journal. 2016;5(12):149-69. (Full Text in persion)
Hosseini zobaidi M. Taj al-aroos men javaher al-ghamoos. 1414, vol 11, editor: Beirut, Dar al-fekr. (Full Text in Arabic)
Ibne Fares. Moujam al-maghaeas al-logha: Qom: Maktab al-aalam al-eslami; 1982. (Full Text in Arabic)
Farahidi Kh. Ketabo al-ayn: Qom, Hejrat publication; 1987. (Full Text in Arabic)
Ibne manzore M. lesan al-arab. . Beirute: daro al- fekr.daro al sad; 1992. (Full Text in Arabic)
Computer Research Center of Islamic Sciences (NOOR) Jami al- ahadith VERSION: 3.5[CD - ROM] ed. Qom2012.
Koleini M. Al-kafi. Tehran: Eslami;1968, vol.1. (Full Text in Arabic)
Amoli M. Wasael al-shia: Qom: Al-al bayt institute; 1983. vol.1. (Full Text in Arabic)
Amoli M. Wasael al-shia.: Qom: Al-al bayt institute; 1983. vol.12. (Full Text in Arabic)
Koleini M. Al-kafi. Tehran: Eslami; 1968, vol.6. (Full Text in Arabic)
Amoli M. Wasael al-shia. 21, editor: Qom: Al-al bayt institute; 1983. vol.21. (Full Text in Arabic)
Amoli M. Wasael al-shia. Qom: Al-al bayt institute 25; 1983. (Full Text in Arabic)
Barghi A MKH. Al - mah’asen. Qom: Daralkotob Eslamiye; (Full Text in Arabic)
Fattale Nishabori M. Rawzat al-waezin va basirat al-mottaezin: Tehran: Nashre Ney; 1987. (Full Text in Persian)
Koleini M. Al-kafi. Tehran: Eslami, vol.8; 1968. (Full Text in Arabic)
Sadough (Ebne Babevei) M. El Al-Sharaya. Qom: Davaree Library;1; 1966. (Full Text in Arabic)
Tabarsi H. Makarem Al-Akhlagh. Qom: Sharif Razi 1991. (Full Text in Arabic)
The book of Jalen that based on Hippocrates’s idea (about origin or al-aotoghossat): http://ghbook.ir. 161; (Full Text in Arabic)
Al-Ghorashi A. Describing of Hippocrates’s Chapters: Tehran: The institute of medical history studies & Islamic medicine & alternative medicine; 2005. (Full Text in Arabic)
Myrabzadh ardekani, Shams Ardekani M, Keshavarz M, Nazem E, Minaei M. Natural Affairs in Traditional Iranian Medicine. Journal of Islamic and Iranian Traditional Medicine. 1; 2010.315-22. (Full Text in Persian)
Hippocrates. The book of Hippocrates about Endemic diseases. Tehran: Iran University of Medical Sciences: http://ghbook.ir; No. 10036. (Full Text in Arabic)
Faali M. Sensory perception in Avicenna's viewpoint. Qom: Islamic advertising Publications Office; 1997. (Full Text in Persian)
Miri M. Steamy Soul in Islamic and Contemporary Philosophy. Hekmat Moaser Journal, autumn and winter. 2014;5(3).81-99. (Full Text in Persian)
Avicenna H. Al-Adwiah al-Qalbiah. http://lib.eshia.ir/73057/1/222.
Naghizadeh H, Karami F. The comparative Hadiths in Osole Kafi, consistent or inconsistent. Olome Hadith journal. 2013;17(2):57-89. (Full Text in Persion)
Computer Research Center of Islamic Sciences (NOOR). CRCoIS. Diraya al-noor. VERSION: 184.108.40.206[ CD – ROM]. ed. Qom,2011.
Feyze kashani M, Alvafi, Esfahan. Imam Amir al-momenin library. Esfahan1985. (Full Text in Arabic)
Tarihi F. Maj’ma al - bahrayn. Tehran: Mortazaviye 1996. (Full Text in Arabic)
Majlisi A. Bahar Al-Anwar. Beirut1982. (Full Text in Arabic)
Majlisi A. Merat Al-Oghol fi shrhe akhbare ale al-rasol. Tehran1983. (Full Text in Arabic)
Amoli M. Al-fosol al-mohemmah fi osol al-aemmah. Qom: Imam Reza institute;1997. vol.3. (Full Text in Arabic)
Sadough (Ebne Babevei) M. Man la yahzor Al-faghih. Qom: islmic publication; 1992, vol.1. (Full Text in Arabic)
Amoli M. Wasael al-shia. Qom: Al-al bayt institute; 1983. vol.2. (Full Text in Arabic)
Under Bethesda Statement on Open Access Publishing (June 20, 2003), cience-research Journal of Pizhūhish dar dīn va salāmat are fully compliant with open access mandates, by publishing its articles under Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0). Authors retain copyright of their work and can deposit their publication in any repository. This means that articles can be freely reused by the author and others as long as the article is properly cited. Published articles in Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences Journals can be deposited immediately into an online repository without any cost. This articles can be, printed, archived in a collection, included in course-packs, and distributed without restrictions. Please read the full Creative Commons License for further information.